View Single Post
  #2  
Old 05-04-2007, 10:35 AM
Sherman Sherman is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Ph. D. School
Posts: 3,999
Default Re: Sherman\'s \"Toward a Skill Ratio\" -- better if it got there

Creed,
I appreciate your honesty with the article. Believe me, the original intention of the article was to provide the calculations (as a matter of fact, I already have them completed). Due to spacing issues, I felt an original draft of the article had to be cut into two pieces for a few reasons.

First, it would have been nice to only demonstrate the calculations. However, I felt I would be criticized for not fully explaining where those calculations came from. Additionally, while it may seem that I could have simply attached the calculations at the bottom, there are a few more complexities with the calculations that I intend to address next month. Just attaching calculations without dealing with these issues would have been mis-representative.

Second I could not be sure how many of the readers would be familiar with the pearson-product moment correlation. I felt that an explanation of the said correlation beyond what was put in the article would also have been too lengthy and unnecessary. Which is why this phrase,

[ QUOTE ]
"For those unfamiliar with the correlation, a simple web search will yield many results explaining its function."

[/ QUOTE ],

was added. I thought this was the best way to handle readers at different "statistical" education levels because it (1) allows someone who doesn't care to just keep reading, (2) allows someone who already knows what I am talking about to just keep reading, and (3)provides someone who doesn't know but wants to know, a place to find the answer.

In terms of defining my terms, I clearly did so by providing the definition of the formulas. Just mentioning that if anyone wanted to know more about those formulas, they are relatively easy to find.

Again, thanks for your honesty. If you are looking for skill calculations, next month you will not be dissapointed.

Ryne Sherman
Reply With Quote