View Single Post
  #5  
Old 08-30-2007, 02:51 PM
rbenuck4 rbenuck4 is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Saving babies
Posts: 723
Default Re: \"All in?\" asked as a question, not a statement - ruling?

[ QUOTE ]
I say Player B just called.

The only reason I say that is, maybe he'll learn a lesson, and not allow the words "all-in" to come out of his mouth unless he wants to put all his chips in.

Rule this a call, and I'll bet the next time Player B is in this spot, he'll say something like, "Excuse me? I didn't quite hear you. Did you say that you were all-in?"

[/ QUOTE ]

In both examples, the words "all in" were spoken. What is the difference between the question "all in?" and the statement "did he say all in?" I rule that this was a question, and he should get an answer, he should not have to call here.
Reply With Quote