[Small Fry]

[ QUOTE ]
Small Fry, I take it you don't play in cardrooms often? This is a very common situation. If A mucks face-down, B wins. If A throws his cards face-up anywhere on the table, it's a showdown.

I always muck immediately when this happens.

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree that this is will most likely be the ruling.

And it ignores the definition of muck. See my response to Taso for information on that.

I'm debating this for the sake of a good debate....(I've been told I'm a little demented this way sometimes) as it seems to me that while it is accepted that a players hand when face up is live there are no facts to back it up. Just because everyone thinks something doesn't make it correct, (or the world really would be flat)

So, if you're up for it, feel free to invalidate my arguments with your own set facts.

Perhaps someone can provide a defintion of "tabling ones hand"? I can't find one.