View Single Post
  #25  
Old 08-09-2007, 11:53 PM
durron597 durron597 is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Folding
Posts: 30,000
Default Re: FAO MH - re: Melchiades

all,

i agree with pretty much everything mike has said (see diablo's point 1) and i agree 110% with mat's post.

yeti,

why NOT leave the notes there? unless the notes are blatantly false (i.e. never happened at all, haha jman [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img]), the worst thing that can happen is there's maybe 100 characters of text stored on this site which has 10 million posts. whoop-de-doo.

why do you refuse to consider the possibility that you are wrong about Melchiades? there was a time when not everyone realized all the bad things about Degen, and at one point Degen was a valuable strat poster. yvesaint was also a valuable strat poster at one point. I am not accusing Melchiades of anything (in fact my only interactions with him have been nothing but positive) but on the chance that three months from now someone else accuses Melchiades of spamming the notes should be there to make the mod who is notified go "heyyyyyyyy wait a minute, maybe the false alarm 3 months ago wasn't really a false alarm".

[ QUOTE ]
if the positions were reversed, i would reply to this thread with

'heh, oops, guess i acted a bit quickly there. sorry, thanks for tidying up after me'

[/ QUOTE ]

this assumes that you are not the one who is wrong. perhaps, you are. (and perhaps not, again, i am not accusing Melchiades of anything) even if there is only a 1% chance you are wrong, it's still better to leave the notes.
Reply With Quote