View Single Post
  #42  
Old 12-01-2007, 10:12 PM
BluffTHIS! BluffTHIS! is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: I can hold my breath longer than the Boob
Posts: 10,311
Default Re: Of Climate Models and Hurricane Predictions

[ QUOTE ]
I don't know the actual numbers, they're not conveniently published in a summary table anywhere. But click the link. Much of the reasoning and understanding and quantification of the effects on different sectors is solid, and reports have been done on this very thing, including by relatively disinterested parties such as insurance companies and the world bank There's even a pretty graph with errors bars for you.

[/ QUOTE ]


Phil and wacki,

Note that I have not been asking for the complete analysis and how the various parts of the equation were derived. In fact I'm not even asking for any number except the degree of certainty as to the accuracy of the models. And as I said, I don't follow this closely so I haven't read and am not going to read reams of studies and data. However since you two and others are speaking authoritatively on same, surely one of you *should* be able to answer my question.

I mean how can any layperson who is being told something by scientists along with recommended actions, not ask for a degree of certainty number as to the scientific models that led to the predictions.

If none of you can answer this question, or refuse to knowing the answer, then I find that very telling.




Doctor: I did some tests and although they aren't totally reliable, they indicate you *might* have something serious. I recommend an expensive operation not covered by insurance followed by a long and painful recovery.

Patient: What do you mean by "not totally reliable/accurate"?

Doctor: I can't quantify it for you but I can refer you to several medical journal articles on the methodology of those tests and statistical analysis of the data.

Patient: Well if you've read all of them and are using that information as the basis of your diagnosis, why can't you just tell me how accurate those testing methods are?

Doctor: Just trust me you stupid layperson! Get that operation!

Patient: I think I'll just go either look for a second opinion or check out alternative therapies.
Reply With Quote