View Single Post
  #21  
Old 09-25-2007, 03:14 PM
Maulik Maulik is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Amsterdam
Posts: 7,758
Default Re: Settle a strange question: Is a watch an organon?

Here is an official response from Merriam-Webster:

Dear Kyle,

Organon is frequently used as the collective title for the treatises of
Aristotle although the word also appears in the works of other philosophers
such as Johann Heinrich Lambert, whose principal philosophical work is
titled "New Organon or Thoughts on the Search for Truth and the Distinction
between Error and Appearance" (1764).

Our evidence for the word shows that it is most often used in philosophical
or scientific contexts as the definition in our Online Dictionary indicates
(the sense-divider "specifically" means that the part of the definition that
reads "a body of principles of scientific or philosophic investigation" is
the predominant meaning). That being said, the broader definition "an
instrument for acquiring knowledge" is provided to cover cases where the
word appears in more general contexts.

I've drawn this distinction to show that a watch is not an organon, and that
organon is not used in writing to mean watch. The question that you are
asking about does not relate to what the word organon means, but rather to
the nature of reality.

From a philosophical standpoint, your question does not have a simple
answer. I can't provide you with a definitive answer, but I happened to
notice that this very question is posted online at the following Web site:

http://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/sh...03&Main=12
143117

The comments have been posted for over a year, but perhaps you will find
some of them relevant.

Sincerely,


Anne Eason
Merriam-Webster Editorial Department
Springfield, MA 01102
http://Merriam-Webster.com
http://unabridged.Merriam-Webster.com
Reply With Quote