Re: And the winner is.....??
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Not really. You need to define "tosses his hand away." Did he do it face up? Face down?
Face up, whoever has the best hand wins.
Face down, Player B wins.
[/ QUOTE ]
How is this for a definition: Muck, according to Robert's rules is "to discard ones hand" . To "discard" means "to throw away or get rid of". So we have Muck meaning to throw away or to get rid of ones hand. No mention of the position of the cards or where they're thrown.
So we have a situation where it is Player A's turn to act. He has been called and now, as first to act, he can either show his hand or he can muck it. By the defininition above, by tossing his hand into the middle of the table, or away, he has elected to muck.
[/ QUOTE ]
SF, you are really being a nit. If you were to ever try this at a casino you'd have the entire table laughing at you. I suggest you re-think your definitions in light of reality.
|