View Single Post
  #4  
Old 07-14-2007, 04:19 PM
Phil153 Phil153 is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 4,905
Default Re: Another global climate docu: CBC - Global Warming Doomsday Called

Ad hominem - no. The credentials of the people making claims are of direct importance. The guy at 28:20 (I kid you not) points to an old tree on the beach on an island, and points out that if the sea was rising, the tree wouldn't be there any more!

Slander - where? Slander doesn't exist without a lie.

Circumvention of board filter - lol

Exchange of information - yes. I point out quite correctly that the video was made in 2004 and criticizes the 2001 report, whose predictions have largely been verified so far. The sophistication of analysis and evidence has also improved a great deal since 2001, all supporting the theory BTW.

Arguments - you posted a half hour video link. If you have specific claims in the video that you think are credible, it's up to you to bring them up for discussion.

You're welcome.

edit: Why are you posting a 3 year old video link anyway??
Reply With Quote