[mustmuck]

I much prefer 1 to 2.

Still not wild about 1 though! When these guys full pot the river I find that they're strong a lot of the time. If I'd seen him play this could change though. If it wasn't for the size of his river bet I'd like this one a lot more.

I think 2 is terrible. I don't think you described villain, but if he is anything like villain 1 they rarely bet fold a river. You're saying that you're bluffing, so I assume you think he'll fold a boat? What boat does he bet/fold?