View Single Post
  #20  
Old 09-19-2007, 08:48 AM
zasterguava zasterguava is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: St Kilda, Australia
Posts: 1,760
Default Re: Can someone educate me on anarchism?

Thanks for your reply. You enfuriated me whilst also giving me a chuckle. Well done on that.

[ QUOTE ]
The O'RLY owl wishes he could be here, but he had less ridiculous claims to attend to.

[/ QUOTE ]

The anarchist tradition has unilaterally pertained to a socialist position. The 'classic' writers I mentioned are echoed by all serious modern anarchists including ACists (yes I have read from ACist sources too).

[ QUOTE ]
If I dig up 5 names of Anarcho-Capitalists then have I rebutted you?

[/ QUOTE ]

No. But you would struggle to name a single anarchist thinker whom proposes capitalism and free markets who has gained the notoriety and respect of the forementioned anarchists.

[ QUOTE ]
If you'd like to explain *why* these writings should make us question AC, feel free.

[/ QUOTE ]
I should hope they would challenge your opinion. It is the purpose of much of their work afterall. I have certainly found some of the more coherent and thought out responses on this forum to have challenged my view in instances.
[ QUOTE ]
Some of us actually evaluate what is being said, and do not just assume that since someone stated the position that zasterguava approves of that it must be worthwhile.


[/ QUOTE ]

So allow the OP to evaluate and not restrict his/her learning to ACist ideas by dismissing the forefathers of anarchism as teenage angst victims?

[ QUOTE ]
Well first of all this is wrong; or at least, grossly exaggerated.

[/ QUOTE ]

It is not wrong or grossly exaggerated... It's fact and it would be no depriment to any ACist to acknowledge that.

[ QUOTE ]
For starters, OP specifically asked about AC. The only one being close-minded here is you, who is aimlessly attacking positions that someone specifically asked about and others attempted to explain.

[/ QUOTE ]
It is evident that the OP is extremely ignorant of anarchism as demonstrated by his/her blurring between distinctions between ACism and actual anarchism. One can suppose a thread with the title "Can someone educate me on anarchism?" would yield some responses about its forefathers, traditions and history and not only revisionist opinion dismissing everything else.

[ QUOTE ]
It's pretty amazing that you actually think that; let alone say it out loud.

[/ QUOTE ]
I don't suppose you have gone through all my posts but I have shown a lot of interest in ACism and if anyone asked me about anarchism I would be sure not to be completely dismissive or censory concerning ACism (as you all have demonstrated towards the main branches of anarchism).
Reply With Quote