[hoyasnaxa]

[ QUOTE ]
They were 4-1 through 5 games.

Did McNabb suck in the Tampa game? Yes. Were the Eagles historically unlucky to lose that game? Yes.

[/ QUOTE ]

It wasnt being unlucky, it was goddamn McNabb. He doesnt throw into the endzone right before half, he gives the bucs all their points, and in the 2:00 drill, he does what he always does which is suck, and throw to Westbrook everytime and hope he bails them out. And of course after the game says we need to work on this, we need to do this, how about you need to not throw directly to Ronde Barber every pass moron?

In the Giants game McNabb started off well, and in the 2nd half basically took the entire offense off the field as he threw directly into the ground on every 3rd down play. The defense was on the field the whole second half because of McNabb coasting like he always does.

Yes Garcia and McNabb have similar stats, but what they do on 3rd downs, in important situations, and the effect they had on the rest of the team is hugely positive to one side (Garcia) and negative on the other.

Go Jimmy Rollins.