[Thinky]

[ QUOTE ]
Would you make this trade?

I give up: Jeff Garcia, Jamal Lewis, Dante Stallworth, Kellen Winslow.

I get: Peyton Manning, Lawrence Maroney, Julius Jones, Bo Scaife.

14 team league, .5 pts per reception, TD passes worth 6 pts. My current QBs are Garcia and Kitna. I have Addai, Benson, and Lewis. WR's would be Housh, B. Marshall, and Crayton if I give up Stallworth. Of course losing Winslow would hurt, so is the upgrade with Manning and Maroney worth it?

[/ QUOTE ]

I don't think this is a good trade for you. You are giving up a lot of good players for a QB who is not producing great fantasy numbers.

I would stay put if I were you.