[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Just to make it clear why looking at career W/L records and declaring that Roethlisberger must be better than Palmer is stupid, here are the
DVOA rankings for Cincinatti's and Pittsburgh's defenses from 2004, when both Palmer and Roethlisberger started playing, through the first half of 2007:
Pittsburgh: 13th, 2nd, 10th, 2nd.
Cincinatti: 31st, 20th, 25th, 29th.
Don't you think the fact that QB1 has had one of the league's best defenses, while QB2 has had probably the league's worst defense makes their relative W/L records a very poor way to compare them?
[/ QUOTE ]
If you'd read the thread, you'd know that OP has ignored any and all logic and prefers to judge QBs by SB rings.
[/ QUOTE ]
You never know, some people just haven't heard the Good News yet. We can't condemn this soul to Sports Fan Hell without first making an honest effort to spread the Word. That's why, in my last post, I decided to call his method of judging QBs "very poor," instead of "profoundly retarded."