[KyrosMother]

[ QUOTE ]
I wrote this up last night. I like my order….a lot.


<u>In order of least to most wolfy</u>

Jgunnip – pretty sure he is the only sane one here. He did vote for OH over Nez on Day 1. Everyone else alive (except Skill) was on someone else Day 1.

Eskimo – claims FGP. Easy role to fake claim, unless challenged. No one has challenged him, so he is not high on my list - but I am watching him.

Mark – had seen no reason to suspect him until he made his claim. If he is a wolf, it seems like it was an unnecessary claim to make at that time. Would he really expose himself like that? I didn’t like his “explanations” afterwards either – but seeing as I didn’t believe Nick either, I don’t think I should use this against him....

FCBL – has been pretty quiet all game and was on my villager list until he came in and started suspecting me, after he hasn’t all game. Felt like he was trying to align himself where it would do him the most good. Says he “faked seer” and didn’t die, so either VR or I must be a wolf. I have also “faked seer” and am still alive. Lots of people “fake seer” during a game (intentionally or unintentionally) and don’t die – so I don’t put as much stock in this as Monk apparently does (FCBL and Monk???)

Tar – I have had him on my wolf list since Day 1. Claims ninja. If he is a new player, I am not sure how he would know about a ninja role – but it is possible. Hasn’t told us of any switches or anything he has done. I keep him on my wolf list.

Boiler – has been on my wolf list for a few days now. I still think there is a good chance I was blocked because he and Tar are wolves.




I didn’t include Skill, as he is dying anyway. Actually, I think he is a neutral. Doesn’t appear he has followed much of the game. Comes in every now and then with odd comments. Otherwise, has been very quiet.

[/ QUOTE ]


I haven't changed much of my opinion above, except:

1) jgunnip is obviously good

2) skill is very likely good/neutral. I am pretty sure he was poisoned Night 5. Last night was Night 8. He didn't die. That says to me that he probably has the same kind of powers OH had and I don't think DMK would give 2 evils that power. I would like to hear what he has to say about all this, though. For now, he stays on my good/neutral list. At this point, maybe even higher than Monk. (Of course, if I have my days all messed up, just ignore me....)

Also, if boiler was a bad little pumpkin, then there is likely still a bad big pumpkin out there. We know Monk is probably a big pumpkin - but I am not sure we have any definitive proof he is good...because pumpkins are chaotic. Has a good big pumpkin died yet? If not, and no one challenges Monk - then I would say he is likely good. So unless a good big pumpkin has already died or one dies soon - I am keeping Monk on my villager list.

That leaves Mark, FCBL, and Tar. I won't be voting until I have had a chance to reread some stuff tonight and everyone has posted.