Re: Spin Off Logic Problem From Genius-Religion Debate
I don't think either question is actually consistent with the OP. In particular, we have enough specific information about claims regarding God that we don't need to rely on this sort of reasoning. Also, that new information may change the problem. And I don't think a specific claim should be evaluated based on its popularity - the "smart people" standard is at best a last-ditch when no other information is available IMO.
|