[sethypooh21]

Well sure, but both Tevez and Torres have certainly indicated that they are going to be good premiership players. I mean even when it took Tevez forever to score for West Ham last year, he was clearly their best player by a country mile. Well him or Marlon Harewood...

I see what you're saying about waiting and seeing, but based on the information we have, I don't see how you can't rate these two pretty highly. If a year from now, they look like Sheva, then we can change our opinion...FWIW, I would definitely take Torres over Keane. Less sure about Tevez, because they are pretty similar players and Keane is at least somewhat proven at this level.