[mikech]

some more thoughts: this movie was so retarded that it defeated its own purpose. the ending was supposed to show how crowe's character turned from "bad" to "good," or at least that he found that there's some "good" within him after all. (see the exchange when bale's son says to him, "you're not ALL bad," which crowe denies and says, "yes i am.")

so crowe's supposed to achieve some sort of redemption with the ending. except, by killing his whole gang, he actually does just the opposite! throughout the movie, charlie shows himself to be nothing but an outstanding second-in-command: capable, devoted, steadfast and true. (that is, in relation to crowe; to others he is sadistic and cold-blooded.)

he demonstrates his gratitude and loyalty repeatedly. when crowe is captured he could easily make himself the gang's leader if he wanted (he IS the de facto leader during the entire rescue mission), but he doesn't even think of usurping that presumably lucrative role for himself. instead, he leads a long and arduous mission to track down and rescue crowe, eventually succeeding in the nick of time.

easy question: would any one of you guys NOT want to have a friend and colleague who's as loyal as charlie? would you not want him on your side in a battle?

well, crowe shows his thanks by shooting charlie thru the chest. twice. the second time with his gun barrel pressed up against the original entry wound, just for good measure. some redemption.