I like little children's toys. Matchbox cars, finger puppets, GI Joes etc. I am definitely not a fan of anything poker related (imo anything marketed as a card protector is inherently lame)
Here is a picture of one of my favorite card protectors, I think it cost me $0.99 at the hotel gift shop (I asked the photographer if he wanted a picture of me and he very quickly responded "no, just your card protector" lol donkaments)