[Oink]

I think you are missing value big time here.

The board is drawy meaning a) there is more value in a raise and b) he will put you on draws and call down more.

This is a blind steal situation meaning he will give you less credit as you should (correctly) expect him to have a wide range.

I think the flop is a pretty easy c/r as a tight player will often check behind the turn with worse hands that calls down a flop c/r. If you think he 2nd barrels a lot, even on this flop with worse hands you could c/c flop and c/r turn. Against an unknown at AP 5/T I wouldnt do that tho.