Re: I\'m Technically Wrong On One Aspect of My Debate With Txaq
[ QUOTE ]
the existence of those other books DOES lower the probability that my theories are correct.
[/ QUOTE ]
I agree with you that as a math question only this is true about any theory.
Look at these two statements from the same paragraph:
[ QUOTE ]
And I can't wiggle out of that fact by alluding to any mentions by me of detractors
myriad detractors is a LEGITIMATE objection, that an outsider can bring up and they must meet the objection to HIS satisfaction.
[/ QUOTE ]
The first is basically the math question. The second is what Tx and I are saying. So you do see the difference. Though I techniclly disagree with "HIS satisfaction" and would repace it with "valid reason".
And I guess it is all a fine point. Content trumps math.
|