[onthebutton]

I would guess that most here would have a hard time distinguishing between a photo taken with a high quality dSLR and a 35mm camera.

I would agree with El D that there is something more appealing about an image that's "undoctored", however. Even digital images fall into this category, for me. I have no idea why, but maybe it's that when we see something we can at some level tell the difference between a direct representation of what our eye would see and a processed version of what someone thinks our eye SHOULD see.