VY\'s future vs others
 

Talking to a friend, couldn't come to a consensus. Two questions:

Re: VY\'s future vs others
 

Cutler

and I'm a Jake Plummer fan.

Re: VY\'s future vs others
 

The first really depends on the rest of the team. For most teams I take Vick next year.

The second is pretty speculative, I went with Cutler mostly because of the team around him.

Re: VY\'s future vs others
 

BTW, I meant assuming that each team is the same save for the QB. So while the Broncos might be the best team next year, that doesn't necessarily mean you want Cutler. I also think that Vick, given the right offense (put him in a run and shoot or something similar to the Bear's offense, predicated on the threat of the deep ball) would be a top five QB.

QB
 

Vick, Cutler. I would take MV next year since he is established and I know what to expect from him next year. Personally I think Vick is a top 1/3 of the NFL QB.

Cutler is supposed to be a QB with a lot of talent and will be on a Broncos team that has all the tools to succeed even if he does not turn out to be such a great QB.

Re: QB
 

Watched Vince close up all through his college days and was amazed on a weekly basis. He is simply a freak of human nature and loves it when people doubt him.

I would not be surprised if he is the best QB in the NFL in the next 3-4 years.

Re: QB
 

[ QUOTE ]
Watched Vince close up all through his college days and was amazed on a weekly basis. He is simply a freak of human nature and loves it when people doubt him.

I would not be surprised if he is the best QB in the NFL in the next 3-4 years.

[/ QUOTE ]

I'l take a 35 year old Peyton Manning over VY in 3 years

Re: VY\'s future vs others
 

Next year I think it's close between Alex Smith and Matt Leinart, assuming the same supporting cast*. Obviously if you get the whole team you want Cutler, because the Broncos are way better than the rest of those teams.

Long-term I'd take Leinart.

*I mean if you get the same supporting cast regardless of which QB you take. ie, I'm the Cleveland Browns and I get to chose from each of these quarterbacks.

Re: VY\'s future vs others
 

http://images.sportsnetwork.com/foot...omo_awards.jpg

Re: VY\'s future vs others
 

[ QUOTE ]

I'l take a 45 year old Peyton Manning over VY ever

[/ QUOTE ]