Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

As usual IMDB turns out to be pretty reliable for seeding purposes. This time we have three number one seeds and one number three seed making it to the final four.

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

Question, probably already answered. Are we voting on them just as movies, or are we voting on how they hold up to the comic books? Because I don't really know much about comic books, but anyone who thinks X2 is a better movie than Batman should be shot.

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

Vote for the movie you feel is better.

Swede

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

I really can't believe people like the Batman with keaton/nicholson. Keaton's batman is only good if you compare it to Clooney's.

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

IMO Sin City is clearly the best of all of these. I appear to be in the minority though.

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

[ QUOTE ]
I really can't believe people like the Batman with keaton/nicholson. Keaton's batman is only good if you compare it to Clooney's.

[/ QUOTE ]

Tim Burton is Orson Welles next to Joel Schumacher.

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

my order for these is:

sin city
batman begins
batman
x2

but i won't be too upset if the 2 batmans swap places

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

[ QUOTE ]
I really can't believe people like the Batman with keaton/nicholson. Keaton's batman is only good if you compare it to Clooney's.

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm having a tremendously difficult time deciding between Batman and X2. Possibly the toughest matchup in the entire tourney.

Swede

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

[ QUOTE ]
IMO Sin City is clearly the best of all of these.

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree.

Re: Greatest Comic Book Movie of All Time - Final Four
 

I'm Batman. No wait, *I'm* batman. No, um...I AM Batman. I'm BATman. Oh hell...