New sticky discussion thread
 

This is where you get on your soapbox and launch into a dramatic diatribe about the new uNL Sticky.

Readysetgogogogo

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

if somone makes a bad thread are oneliners +EV?


and...excellent post.

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

2nd!!!

I read the whole thing, and then I clicked the "Bad Threads" links because those are more fun than the good ones.

I then clicked all the good ones just to see if any threads I started were deemed as one, alas, no.

I then realized I don't really start that many threads. :[

Nice RR.

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

Thanks, one liners don't help a whole lot. Most people see hands and will say "standard" but when you are learning you may not understand fully why it is standard.

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

Personally I don't think there should be a total ban on one liners. A forum with as much traffic as uNL simply can't support 100% verbose responses to the same questions over & over. Its a hard problem though, because its easy to fall in to 100% one liners. And while it might be true that the best way to learn the game is to figure out on your own through study & diligence why a one-liner reply is the correct answer (or not the correct answer), its difficult or impossible to do this if you don't have a foundation of knowledge to base this study on. And if uNL serves any purpose, it is to provide a place to build this foundation of knowledge.

So cliff notes, I don't know what the right solution is but I think its somewhere between 100% ban & 100% one-liners.

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

[ ] Ban one liners LDO

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

I think by banning 1 liners, you are really losing both good & bad posters, and I guess it depends on which one you think outweighs the other. Personally, I prefer you leave the 1 liners, that way at least if 20 responses in thread say "fold turn," you a) get a consensus that you should fold turn. b) still get a post in there somewhere why you should fold turn, because someone always elaborates. Either way works I guess, allowing 1-liners adds both noise and content.

I know I started posting like 10x less since the 1 liner rule, since I usually post & play, and so do a lot of people I'm sure. Now instead I just surf OOT. [img]/images/graemlins/laugh.gif[/img]

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

The one liner thing has been discussed to death in the other thread. Let it die.

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

alright here is my contribution of threads i thought had good discusion and provoked some thought...

[censored] Value Town by poke

derosnec on combinations and ranges

AZ and his not so nut flush (with dick waiving)

tubasteve on multitabling

AZ has AK preflop


orange double barrels


gelford has 2 rules

EDIT: new title to be: jumpmanHOLLA

please [img]/images/graemlins/laugh.gif[/img]

Re: New sticky discussion thread
 

I COULD DO WITHOUT THE RICKROLL FFS.