Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

Unvote

I'm officially changing my stance on LastChange being a seer peek. I seriously doubt that CinCy would peek a fellow BGGer on n0. Her peek (if there even was one) is kyro! He's the only non-BGG player that she provided a read on.

*Kyro is Paranoid* Our goal should be to figure out what she meant by paranoid (remember, she doesn't know kyro or his personality).

The context says everything. Does anyone know what kyro's posts were preceding that statement? I'm too lazy to look back.

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

^^^^

Post # 1k

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

whatever, i feel like i'm talking to a brick wall. maybe its just because there are only like 3 ppl here right now

just let the record show that i believe

a) chuckles/antidan were govt' kills
b) cincity was a revolutionary kill and not a seer-hunt
c) lastchance is not directly implicated by cincity's death due to b)
d) i have no opinion of those who pushed lastchance early due to cincity's death, and may even lean villager on them since wolves may not immediately think to credit the cincity death to themselves
e) i don't actually think we should be lynching from books/nich today; i just really want to be right about books. the total lack of posting from both of them is really irritating
f) obviously we'd have to lynch nich if we *have* to choose between only those 2
g) i don't have a great 3rd candidate atm because kokiri is posting villagery recently. one of these utr ppl can surely go though
h) also, at least one of mets/OH is likely wolf

i think thats all...

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

OH, please agree or disagree w/ each point above, ty

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

and luckay too

and....

rez

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

OH,
way ahead of you [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

[ QUOTE ]
CINCITY D1:

[ QUOTE ]
*note to self*

kyro sounds paranoid a bit parnoid??

[/ QUOTE ]

given that "CinCity was killed - she was the Revolution Computer Expert. Each night she got a full role peek of a player of her choice." , its possible that kyro might be some kind of paranoid seer.


[/ QUOTE ]

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

You feel like you're talking to a brick wall because no one is around, but also because we're trying to weed through what you're saying. I personally disagree with about 60-70% of your last post. ESPECIALLY this part:

[ QUOTE ]
b) cincity was a revolutionary kill and not a seer-hunt
c) lastchance is not directly implicated by cincity's death due to b)

[/ QUOTE ]
IF CinCy was a revolutionary kill and IF (this is a huge if)...IF she would peek a BGGer, it's MORE likely that LC is evil, not less. C'mon, you know the wolves wouldn't kill someone like that to implicate one of their own on d1 of a long game.

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

a) disagree, because i also disagree with b).
agree somewhat on c).
d) i skimmed that part of the thread.
e) depends on your proposed alternative.
f) i dont think i believe books' claim.
guess g) answers e).
h) of the two i think mets is more likely. i dont think OH is evil.

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

[ QUOTE ]
luckay, what do you think?

[/ QUOTE ]
I think it will all be clearer tomorrow so discussion today is really wasted

I'll vote for who you vote for today

Re: The Revolution - Game Thread
 

[ QUOTE ]
i don't see how "the very top" is more likely to point to the leader of the gov't than the leader of the revolution

i also feel like the terminology used in the writeups has been deliberately consistent, and the term "soldier" should be treated in the same manner we've seen it the entire game


[/ QUOTE ]

dmk

You are smarter than this. There is no equivalency between "the soldiers" and "the revolutionary soldiers".

I mean, c'mon. Come up with something that makes more sense than that.