Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

the reason we lost is that chuckles killed me

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
i think every villager thought monk was a villager

[/ QUOTE ]
yeah but they didn't think he was a very good one, didn't give enough attention to his reads, or they would have had the game wrapped up.

[/ QUOTE ]

your very very wrong. if i had had more time at the end things would have gone differently. i dont know what else to say.

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree 100% with this... The walls were crumbling for the wolves and all the evidence was out there in the thread. It just needed to be pieced together.

i.e. If someone just cross referenced, who was newted, who could possibly be the newter, along with Clowns list and confirmed villagers, KM is the only possible newter. I sat on my hands the whole game.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
the reason we lost is that chuckles killed me

[/ QUOTE ]
I'd do it again

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
the reason we lost is that chuckles killed me

[/ QUOTE ]
I'd do it again

[/ QUOTE ]

thats cause you werent pro village ldo

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

yeah, I couldn't let you try to start up a wagon on me

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
i think every villager thought monk was a villager

[/ QUOTE ]
yeah but they didn't think he was a very good one, didn't give enough attention to his reads, or they would have had the game wrapped up.

[/ QUOTE ]

your very very wrong. if i had had more time at the end things would have gone differently. i dont know what else to say.

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree 100% with this... The walls were crumbling for the wolves and all the evidence was out there in the thread. It just needed to be pieced together.

i.e. If someone just cross referenced, who was newted, who could possibly be the newter, along with Clowns list and confirmed villagers, KM is the only possible newter. I sat on my hands the whole game.

[/ QUOTE ]
someone did that (jgunnip or Monk?) and came up with KM as witch. Maybe I should have left hints as to who I newted, to help the village narrow it down more.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

oh yeah that reminds me, the million dollar question.... who did newt antidan n1?

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

We (KM) did.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

=(

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
i think every villager thought monk was a villager

[/ QUOTE ]
yeah but they didn't think he was a very good one, didn't give enough attention to his reads, or they would have had the game wrapped up.

[/ QUOTE ]

your very very wrong. if i had had more time at the end things would have gone differently. i dont know what else to say.

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree 100% with this... The walls were crumbling for the wolves and all the evidence was out there in the thread. It just needed to be pieced together.

i.e. If someone just cross referenced, who was newted, who could possibly be the newter, along with Clowns list and confirmed villagers, KM is the only possible newter. I sat on my hands the whole game.

[/ QUOTE ]
someone did that (jgunnip or Monk?) and came up with KM as witch. Maybe I should have left hints as to who I newted, to help the village narrow it down more.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think you did leave hints. n1 you were blocked/missed, n2 tarheels?, n3 mark? As a villager i didn't think you newt VR or books.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
oh yeah that reminds me, the million dollar question.... who did newt antidan n1?

[/ QUOTE ]

[ QUOTE ]
We (KM) did.

[/ QUOTE ]

For some reason this makes me very happy.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Seer stuff sorts itself so no need to waste a lynch there

[/ QUOTE ]

That is absolutely incorrect given the power OurHouse was claiming. You can NOT take a rule and just blindly apply it to every game regardless of game dynamic. Not killing OurHouse that day was terrible.

[/ QUOTE ]

Did OH counter claim seer? No? So you listen to the claimed seer, and lynch his wolf. You only "let the seer situation sort itself out" when there's multiple competing claims.

DMK: Game balance was good. Impressive for putting it together on the fly. I can't balance a game with months of thought.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
oh yeah that reminds me, the million dollar question.... who did newt antidan n1?

[/ QUOTE ]
I newted you I think (whoever got arrested) but the arrest took precedence. When I first saw the morning announcements I thought either dmk had made a mistake (impossible ldo) or there was some kind of target switching going on. I lol'd when I found out two different good players had wanted to silence monk.