Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

challah

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

Was this the longest WW game ever? I know it's close ... I remember at least one other getting into the high three-thousands.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

It's gotta be the longest from a time standpoint LOL.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

pog replies top 10:

1 - +/- 8251
2 - guitar heros - 4570
3 - AS-XI - Mafia Takeover - 4303
4 - Star trek next gen 2 - 4011
5 - this game - 4002 and counting
6 - malloreon - 3974
7- vendettas 2 - 3622
8 - werewolf:vendettas - 3550
9 - LOTR: The Two Towers - 3549
10 - Old Timers Game - 3362

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
i don't have time to paste complete roleset because i kind of made up the PMs as i went and only have the role-names in a spreadsheet, which you know most of anyway

[/ QUOTE ]

Dammit this is the one thing I was hoping to see from this game.

BASTARD.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes, dmk if you get the chance I'd really like to see a summary of everyone's role and powers as well as a recap of all the night actions. great game I had a lot of fun and it was pretty challenging for me being my first mish mash game.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

LOL I was part of ASXI as well.

POG: The internet's finest collection of long-winded LOLVILLAGERS.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

i was part of +/- iirc [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

Due to the length I think most villagers at the end didn't take the time to go back through the entire thread and reread. I know I didn't.

did tarheels really put the final vote on fcbl?? wow, especially when monk was voting KM. ugh that is just ugly [img]/images/graemlins/frown.gif[/img]

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

jgunnip - you were very good. I knew you were going to be trouble.

In all fairness to Tar - he is new. I thought he did a great job with his ninja stuff. We were not happy to see him alive the next day. Not happy at all. [img]/images/graemlins/tongue.gif[/img] we never saw that coming.

In all fairness to Tokyo (assuming he is really Skill) - he and I were wolves once together in an end game a long time ago. I tried to play this <u>very</u> differently, in hopes of getting him to vote FCBL. I don't know if that convinced him or he had another agenda - but I was really trying to change my style because he had seen me there before. All I know is I really wanted that poison to kick in and for him to die pretty soon...

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
i was part of +/- iirc [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

[/ QUOTE ]

That never happened. For anyone except you. No offense. OK, maybe a little. [img]/images/graemlins/smirk.gif[/img]

Besides, it's not WW.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

It is funny that you lost your star, but still don't have a custom title as a result of +/- but from an OOT porn thread.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
Besides, it's not WW.

[/ QUOTE ]

QFT

it was better than any werewolf game ever played

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Besides, it's not WW.

[/ QUOTE ]

QFT

it was better than any werewolf game ever played

[/ QUOTE ]

lynch mets

Obvious lie.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
It is funny that you lost your star, but still don't have a custom title as a result of +/- but from an OOT porn thread.

[/ QUOTE ]

i asked for a custom title -- durron gave me tries too hard based on +/-
it was too similiar to your title at the time

VR stalks me so she saw my posts in an OOT Porn thread

and the rest is history

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

well if VR doesnt stalk me, then she stalks OOT Porn threads

either way im tittilated

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

That got me to thinking what was the best game ever played on here. The Vendetta games rock. Several of the Mish-Mash games have rocked. I actually really liked reading the Star Trek games.

But come on, it's Miss POG in a rout.

(Yeah, so it's not really a game. Whatever. It's hot, half-naked women. Case closed.)

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
That got me to thinking what was the best game ever played on here. The Vendetta games rock. Several of the Mish-Mash games have rocked. I actually really liked reading the Star Trek games.

But come on, it's Miss POG in a rout.

(Yeah, so it's not really a game. Whatever. It's hot, half-naked women. Case closed.)

[/ QUOTE ]

it never finished even tho me and chuck begged and begged for a conclusion. i am completely unsatisfied and i will not consider it the best anything

PS - congrats guys this thread is 4th place now

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

Don't tell my wife, but I'm sad that VR doesn't stalk me. [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img]

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
jgunnip - you were very good. I knew you were going to be trouble.

In all fairness to Tar - he is new. I thought he did a great job with his ninja stuff. We were not happy to see him alive the next day. Not happy at all. [img]/images/graemlins/tongue.gif[/img] we never saw that coming.

In all fairness to Tokyo (assuming he is really Skill) - he and I were wolves once together in an end game a long time ago. I tried to play this <u>very</u> differently, in hopes of getting him to vote FCBL. I don't know if that convinced him or he had another agenda - but I was really trying to change my style because he had seen me there before. All I know is I really wanted that poison to kick in and for him to die pretty soon...

[/ QUOTE ]

thanks [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img] Up until the very end you pretty way under my wolf radar. When I made my theory post that you were the evil witch I was basically sure you were wolf based on process of elimination and role claims.

I'm curious as to what the wolves' strategy was at the start of the game and how it changed throughout.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

I could care less about the Miss POG conclusion, there were lots and lots and lots of pics regardless.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

Heh - I am not sure we had a strategy. Luckay came in first night with the masonry with Dan and we decided Herbie was the seer. That didn't work out so well.

Then he dies and Dustin is poisoned. So we are down 2 wolves pretty quickly. OH, Boiler, Mark and I just sort of winged it. OH actually wanted to get lynched, because he wouldn't die and it would help clear him. Being peeked by Nick and shot at night by VR hurt that cause greatly.

I was just trying to keep track of who I had silenced, so there would always be someone I could silence. That's why VR had to go and Monk stayed....had we killed Monk and not VR - I have no one to silence the last day and it is tar and VR against Mark and I - and we are in a coinflip.

I think the biggest discussion we had was about Nick. We decided we were toast and needed to take some risks and hope for the best. So we left Nick alive and the village lynches him and then lynches Dustin.

Sometimes the wolves don't need to do much except behave themselves. Sometimes the village does it all for them. We got lucky.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
then theres no point trying to talk you round. if you're lying im safe tonight anyway, if you aren't, well....you either made a bad trade as an evil, fulfilled your role as a neutral, or screwed up bad as a villager.

my villagers, mets, dazbag, zurvan, jgunnip, VR, herbie, jenn fox, GT1T, nez.
my suspects, KM, antidan, dustin, mark, fcbl, OH.

[/ QUOTE ]

if only id labelled my categories "non evil/evil" this would have been a near perfect d1 list.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

From DAY 1...

Pyramid is EVIL

VR is GOOD

KM is NON VILLAGE

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

lol pretty sure everybody knew pyramid was evil after his first 3 posts.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
lol pretty sure everybody knew pyramid was evil after his first 3 posts.

[/ QUOTE ]

Even I knew he was evil. Wait.....



BTW - FCBL - sorry I had to go after you. [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img] There was no one else left to go after. [img]/images/graemlins/frown.gif[/img]

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

gg to all and thanks to the mods

it kinda sucked having figured out the final pieces at the end there and simply not having the time to construct a complete argument.... i was given way more than enough time by village tho so whatever

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

We finally won!! Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay. Great job wolves. Great job KM.

(ok, honestly, I didn't expect to win this one unless KM won it in the final 3)

How you guys didn't lynch Mark is beyond me. We gave up on him the night that Nich turned up seer.

Getting shot by VR was the biggest disappointment for me. I wanted to get lynched so badly (without getting peeked - for maximum effectiveness). DMK said that if I had both lives left and the village lynched me, the writeup would say, "No Lynch" or something to that effect. No way the village lynches me a 2ND time after that. [img]/images/graemlins/tongue.gif[/img]

jgunnip was AMAZINGLY correct in the game and he played awesome from start to finish. We hated him. Same goes for monk and Epi. Village should have rocked our socks off.

Special thanks to DMK for running this. Timed days would've helped, but overall, the game was incredible. Well done.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
That got me to thinking what was the best game ever played on here. The Vendetta games rock. Several of the Mish-Mash games have rocked. I actually really liked reading the Star Trek games.

But come on, it's Miss POG in a rout.

(Yeah, so it's not really a game. Whatever. It's hot, half-naked women. Case will probably never be closed. )

[/ QUOTE ]
FYP

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

GG everyone.

Damn, it really hurt having Nick pick two wolves out of the gate. Ignoring the obvious lynching snafu's, I thought the village did a great job of clearing villagers and finding wolves. It felt like the wolves had their backs to the wall the whole game.

When I made my role claim, I thought hey, let me add a "it only works on villagers" clause in the claim. I figured, we would lynch Boiler, the power would do nothing and I am a little more cleared... I didn't even think about using it on Nich... LOL me. So VR brings it up at literally the exact same time I thought about it... I had to duck for cover, disappear and cross my fingers. Dan - There's an example of me being a moran. [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

Dustin, nice job convincing the village to lynch you. We had you written off... What's more amazing is that you did it without using vowels...

The vast majority of the game the wolve were seer hunting. We were also convinced that there had to be two seers. Esp, because Nich only had a night 1 peek and at the start of the game, DMK was waiting on N0 actions....

Seer hunting really hurts trying to not expose wolves.

80% through the game, we realized that there was no other seer.... Ouch.

BTW, if anyone is ever a wolf together with Boiler, OH, KM, or Pyramid, you're in with a fun team. Dustin, you should have joined wolfchat! Luckay too bad you died N1. [img]/images/graemlins/frown.gif[/img] Great job guys!!!

DMK, thank you for putting the game together and doing a great job of modding it. Awesome.

After this game, I really started to dislike majority only games. The game pace really dragged near the end.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]

After this game, I really started to dislike majority only games. The game pace really dragged near the end.

[/ QUOTE ]

Majority lynch is good. Taking 3-4 days to come to majority is just silly, and there was no reason for it.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

After this game, I really started to dislike majority only games. The game pace really dragged near the end.

[/ QUOTE ]

Majority lynch is good. Taking 3-4 days to come to majority is just silly, and there was no reason for it.

[/ QUOTE ]

Dragging on is a village flaw, not a game flaw.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

what chim/zurv said

majority lynch &gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt; timed lynch imo

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

majority &gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&g t;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt; timed lynch

blame the players, not the game....village doesn't have to prolong days forever

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
what chim/zurv said

majority lynch &gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt; timed lynch imo

[/ QUOTE ]

Yuck.

You should have seen me banging my head when you said it was majority lynch from that point forward. I now have a stickie that says "If you ever think of playing WW again - be sure to ask if it is majority lynch."

It is with all my other stickies that say "If you ever think of playing WW again......"


Regardless - great game and great job with all the roles. I was sure there was a mistake when tar was still alive - until I saw <u>you were very clear</u> that he wouldn't have a NIGHT ACTION. It didn't mean he lost his powers... I am sure it must have been a lot of work keeping everything straight.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
majority &gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;&g t;&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt; timed lynch

blame the players, not the game....village doesn't have to prolong days forever

[/ QUOTE ]

I understand what your getting at... It's just in reality, I've been in two majority games and the end just dragged. You can blame whoever you want, but this game should have ended 10 days ago.

When a game drags on (for whatever reason) the fun factor goes down. Timed games enforce that this will never happen.

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

btw, i'm perfectly fine with the compromise solution of majority with deadlines for all but must-lynch rounds

i think must-lynch should be majority only

i think before must-lynch, majority with a 10pm deadline, or a 2-day deadline is fine (more days if game is more complex, perhaps)

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

here's the problem:

the village/wolves killed off all the ppl that kept the game moving. w/ 7 ppl left almost everyone alive had posted 1-5 times a day, maybe.

*that* is why the game dragged. if dustin/herbie/luckay/etc were alive in the final 7 or whatever, the game would not have dragged at all

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

and the above applies to timed-lynch games too. it always happens.

you have a must-lynch where ppl are making 1 post a day and it takes forever

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

[ QUOTE ]
*that* is why the game dragged. if dustin/herbie/luckay/etc were alive in the final 7 or whatever, the game would not have dragged at all

[/ QUOTE ]
This is true - I'm very impulsive with my voting

Re: Halloween WW - Custome Party (Game Thread)
 

GG wolves. [b]lynch KM[b]