Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

We should really stop talking about saboteur and start talking about finding wolves.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

the more we talk about what the saboteur "might" do the longer this thread gets and the less we achieve today.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

The problem with sending 5 is that we could "Ralph Nader" the vote and end up with 8 (which is a disaster with a trap on it). The 32 vote I'm not thrilled with.

But okay, let's make the push.
I have changed my vote to 5. Let us 5 5 5 gogogo.
I feel that there is < 10% chance that the saboteur chose 5. This is because day1, it's more of a sheep game - the trap is placed where he thinks the village will choose. He didn't expect the Luckay factor to come in.

Let us 5 5 5.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

I was simply planning on voting for whoever had the most posts today, but fmxda is a wolf

if I were worf, I'd kill him tonight

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

i agree that there is no point in strategerizing about the page choice, especially today.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
I was simply planning on voting for whoever had the most posts today, but fmxda is a wolf

if I were worf, I'd kill him tonight

[/ QUOTE ]

i really wish i knew what read you had on him

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

Luckay, have you ever read any CYOA books? (This is a serious question.)

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

voj = villager

That should be easy to remember, especially if vavavoom turns out to be village too.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

Echo all this sabateur talk is inane: 1. We do not know the benfits/detriments of certain decisions where we pick a clean choice. 2. We do not know the harm of the trap. Corralary: we do not know the net effect of a choice, that is, it could well be that our best choice is STILL the best choice even if the trap is set there.

Everyone arguing about this is just confusing the village.

Why is luckay voting himself? Also, why is he ralph nadering the vote, to use his term. (A lot of people have already explicitly said or implied that they are voting 32).

I looked back and I see no jester role ala mish mash, so luckay leaving a vote on himself is very curious.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
if I were worf, I'd kill him tonight

[/ QUOTE ]
It's a good thing you're not then.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

Luckay, durron, fmxda, chim, bluff, fnord, IY, voj

Werewolf? THERE wolf.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
Luckay, durron, fmxda, chim, bluff, fnord, IY, voj

Werewolf? THERE wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]

wow this list is about as wrong as possible

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
Echo all this sabateur talk is inane: 1. We do not know the benfits/detriments of certain decisions where we pick a clean choice. 2. We do not know the harm of the trap. Corralary: we do not know the net effect of a choice, that is, it could well be that our best choice is STILL the best choice even if the trap is set there.

Everyone arguing about this is just confusing the village.

Why is luckay voting himself? Also, why is he ralph nadering the vote, to use his term. (A lot of people have already explicitly said or implied that they are voting 32).

I looked back and I see no jester role ala mish mash, so luckay leaving a vote on himself is very curious.

[/ QUOTE ]

fnord is a villager

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
Luckay, durron, fmxda, chim, bluff, fnord, IY, voj

Werewolf? THERE wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]


Ahhh, the old bobo villager tell.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

Howdy everyone.

If the saboteur voted last night, I think the saboteur will easily go with page 32. Why second level a simple "group think" choice? We need to go page 5 or 8. I think page 8 seems to be a good balance between not being trapped and good for the mercenary band.

Iron, why do you think that the saboteur didn't get a n0 trap set option? I didn't see this when I quickly read through the rules.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

happy birthday gt1t

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

Neil your list is soooo unbelievable that I doubt you're doing this as a wolf (still a possibility though).
Except Luckay of course..

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

OK, Durron, I get it. You're saying that at least some of the wolves are probably UTR, and so my lists are skewed toward those who post?

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

I think neil's list is actually kinda good

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

a list with bluff, chim and fnord? I can get down with that

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
OK, Durron, I get it. You're saying that at least some of the wolves are probably UTR, and so my lists are skewed toward those who post?

[/ QUOTE ]

wtf

i'm saying that the people on your list for the most part have posted very typically for their villager games

why are you trying to put words in my mouth

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

I think more and more you're a wolf traz..

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
a list with bluff, chim and fnord? I can get down with that

[/ QUOTE ]

xcept bluff and fnord (especially fnord) are prob villagers

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
a list with bluff, chim and fnord? I can get down with that

[/ QUOTE ]

xcept bluff and fnord (especially fnord) are prob villagers

[/ QUOTE ]

how many games in a row are you a wolf is this now traz?

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

ok i just created aim chatroom wwcyoa

come talk to me and i will clear you (or catch you if you're a wolf)

<font color="white">jopke</font>

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
a list with bluff, chim and fnord? I can get down with that

[/ QUOTE ]

Funny, I think luckay and fmx are the two most likely in that list. And I think neil is kinda sketchy too.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

Please end discussion on the Saboteur trapping one of the choices. From the author:

[ QUOTE ]
There have been some questions about actions. It occurs to me that this statement may be unclear.

[ QUOTE ]
Everyone got an individual event night 0. The only other actions were the Fortuneteller peek and the Scouting report.

[/ QUOTE ]

When we refer to "individual events" it will always be something impacting only your personal adventure: advancing or hindering your development. "Actions" on the other hand, are anything impacting another player or the overall game environment.

This means that the priest did not protect, the temptress did not block, etc.

[/ QUOTE ]

This means the Saboteur did not place a trap last night. Do not factor this into your decision today.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
a list with bluff, chim and fnord? I can get down with that

[/ QUOTE ]

xcept bluff and fnord (especially fnord) are prob villagers

[/ QUOTE ]

so are luckay, durron, and chim. I also think traz is a villager.

IY is evil.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]

IY is evil.

[/ QUOTE ]

i disagree, but this is one i dont consider myself very sure on

but you're a villager boiler, and that i am sure of

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
Luckay, durron, fmxda, chim, bluff, fnord, IY, voj

Werewolf? THERE wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]

Are you playing flowerew?

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

fnord is off the wolf list and back into the nebulous pit of unknowing. Traz is a villager?, with a question mark since I think he's as capable of mixing things up as I think dmk is, so I doubt I could be sure of him short of a seer peek.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
a list with bluff, chim and fnord? I can get down with that

[/ QUOTE ]

xcept bluff and fnord (especially fnord) are prob villagers

[/ QUOTE ]

how many games in a row are you a wolf is this now traz?

[/ QUOTE ]

I was a villager last game and this game, so that makes it -2

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
a list with bluff, chim and fnord? I can get down with that

[/ QUOTE ]

xcept bluff and fnord (especially fnord) are prob villagers

[/ QUOTE ]

how many games in a row are you a wolf is this now traz?

[/ QUOTE ]

Durron,

I'm not sure where you're trying to go with this post.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
fnord is off the wolf list and back into the nebulous pit of unknowing. Traz is a villager?, with a question mark since I think he's as capable of mixing things up as I think dmk is, so I doubt I could be sure of him short of a seer peek.

[/ QUOTE ]

you really should just add fnord back

fm

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

Durron and neil are probably wolves.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
Durron and neil are probably wolves.

[/ QUOTE ]Grouping me with Durron makes me think Durron's a villager, too.

So I'd like to see a dual wagon of IY and Luckay today, guys. Top top.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
Luckay, durron, fmxda, chim, bluff, fnord, IY, voj

Werewolf? THERE wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]
This list is more or less a list of the last 7 people to post in the thread.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]
fnord is off the wolf list and back into the nebulous pit of unknowing. Traz is a villager?, with a question mark since I think he's as capable of mixing things up as I think dmk is, so I doubt I could be sure of him short of a seer peek.

[/ QUOTE ]

this just looks like "howl, howl, hooooooowl, howl" to me.

Re: Choose Your Own Adventure Vol I: The Road to Eleria
 

[ QUOTE ]

Iron, why do you think that the saboteur didn't get a n0 trap set option? I didn't see this when I quickly read through the rules.

[/ QUOTE ]

DMK quoted it below. I thought I was going crazy for a while.