Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

An acquaintance of mine commented that Eli Manning and Rex Grossman are about the same caliber.

Thoughts on this?

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

he is wrong

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

[ QUOTE ]
An acquaintance of mine commented that Eli Manning and Rex Grossman are about the same caliber.

Thoughts on this?

[/ QUOTE ]

Do you have any?

If not, why make a thread on this when I suspect you know what most will say.

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

[ QUOTE ]
An acquaintance of mine commented that Eli Manning and Rex Grossman are about the same caliber.

Thoughts on this?

[/ QUOTE ]

LMFAO at this in its entirety, and I am a Bears fan!!

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

He's not far off. Also, Eli is overrated.

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

These questions are very hard to answer because a lot of a QB's success is dependent on his offensive line (running game/pass protection).

Give P. Manning/Brady a crappy line and their passing stats would probably go way down. I'm not implying they would be worse than other QBs, just that having a great line helps immensely (and the fact that the Colts line is so banged up makes Manning look even better now).

On raw talent alone, I think E. Manning >> Grossman, but both of them don't seem to have that leadership characteristic. When they make mistakes, they usually have this stupid "lost" look on their faces, and they never seem to be able to motivate their huddles to get the job done consistently.

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

[ QUOTE ]
On raw talent alone, I think E. Manning >> Grossman, but both of them don't seem to have that leadership characteristic. When they make mistakes, they usually have this stupid "lost" look on their faces, and they never seem to be able to motivate their huddles to get the job done consistently

[/ QUOTE ]

I definitely agree with this.

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

If Rex wasn't so inconsistent than I'd say he's easily better. But you never know what you're gonna get with Rex, I still like Rex more though.

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

Well as a Bears fan, it is fun to see the sex cannon unload some bombs, but it is hard to deal with his fumblitis...

Re: Eli Manning/Rex Grossman
 

Peyton threw 6 INTs a few games back. Therefore, I think he's terrible.