What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Was curious. Couldn't find it listed anywhere...

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

34/56 - 328 - 2 - 6
rating: 49.4

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

49.40476190476189

Edited for ridiculously unnecessary accuracy, so that my post adds something despite being second [img]/images/graemlins/wink.gif[/img]

Cool site

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Yeah that's the site I use too. Bookmarked in my FOOTBALL bookmarks folder, which is, unsurprisingly, the largest folder in my bookmarks.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Damn your bookmark, that's why you won this race, I had to find it with Google. It's bookmarked now though [img]/images/graemlins/tongue.gif[/img]

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

anyone else celebrating?

lol at the homers that say it was the kickers fault

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

t would have been 40 points higher if not for the bad call.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

I say it's time to give Sorgi a chance. I know he doesn't have much experience, but 6 picks in one game? Come on.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
34/56 - 328 - 2 - 6
rating: 49.4

[/ QUOTE ]

I recall reading somewhere that if you go 0/100 with 0 INT, your rating is a 50.0

EDIT: The link above says that 0/100 with 0 INT is worth a 39.6

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

ALL OF HIS RECEIVERS WERE HURT HOW CAN HE NOT THROW 6 INTS WITHOUT THEM

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

I'm sick of Bad Peyton. Bring back Good Peyton.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

I hope there still isn't anymore debate on whether he is better than Tom Brady.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

http://tnjn.com/content/storyimage/2...ng_pic.512.jpg

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
I hope there still isn't anymore debate on whether he is better than Tom Brady.

[/ QUOTE ]

you have got to be joking.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
I hope there still isn't anymore debate on whether he is better than Tom Brady.

[/ QUOTE ]
That debate ended several years ago

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I hope there still isn't anymore debate on whether he is better than Tom Brady.

[/ QUOTE ]

you have got to be joking.

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm afraid that they do exist.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I hope there still isn't anymore debate on whether he is better than Tom Brady.

[/ QUOTE ]

you have got to be joking.

[/ QUOTE ]

the good news is that he is

kkf plz troll other forums - you were better at that

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
I say it's time to give Sorgi a chance. I know he doesn't have much experience, but 6 picks in one game? Come on.

[/ QUOTE ]

lol. This needs more love.

Also, the QB rating thing is blasphemous. It needs to go away, like cheerleaders' tops.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

mebbe peyton could do a few more commercials? i'm pretty sure there are one or two companies out there that are currently unrepresented by peyton manning...

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
I hope there still isn't anymore debate on whether he is better than Tom Brady.

[/ QUOTE ]

Coincidentally, the last time Brady had a rating lower than 49 was against the Colts last year:

20/35, 201 yards, 0 TDs, 4 INTs, 34.0 rating

http://www.nfl.com/players/tombrady/...mp;season=2006

The last time Peyton Manning had a worse game was last season in the playoffs against the Ravens

15/30, 170 yds, 0/2 39.6

http://www.nfl.com/players/peytonman...mp;season=2006

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

i love people who say a player is better than another based on one single game performance...every player will have a bad game now and then, it doesnt matter who you are

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

FWIW, list of games with perfect QB ratings. Peyton has 4.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_qua..._passer_rating

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
FWIW, list of games with perfect QB ratings. Peyton has 4.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_qua..._passer_rating

[/ QUOTE ]

Only cause of his great Wide outs, LDO.

Cody

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
FWIW, list of games with perfect QB ratings. Peyton has 4.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_qua..._passer_rating

[/ QUOTE ]

How the hell does Kerry Collins make that list and not Phil Simms during SB XXI? If that doesn't tell you there's something wrong w/ the ratings system, I don't know what does.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Whats wrong with the rating system is you can have a "perfect" game and still throw incompletions. That's not "perfect" imo. The qb rating system is a sham. It is always possible to do better and always possible to do worse.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
FWIW, list of games with perfect QB ratings. Peyton has 4.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_qua..._passer_rating

[/ QUOTE ]

How the hell does Kerry Collins make that list and not Phil Simms during SB XXI? If that doesn't tell you there's something wrong w/ the ratings system, I don't know what does.

[/ QUOTE ]

Simms was 8 points away.

FWIW, that game Collins played was pretty awesome - I definitely remember it. The Giants successfully executed an 80+ yard flea flicker.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
FWIW, that game Collins played was pretty awesome - I definitely remember it. The Giants successfully executed an 80+ yard flea flicker.

[/ QUOTE ]

I remember that game. The flea-flicker was on the first play of the second half. Real back-breaker.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

9/11 218 yds. 2TD/0INT

lol @ Roethlisbergers first perfecto. WTF is this??? QB rating is soooo stupid. And what about when you throw a 10 yard slant and someone runs 70 yards for the TD? This system makes you look so much better because of WR YAC.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Whats wrong with the rating system is you can have a "perfect" game and still throw incompletions. That's not "perfect" imo. The qb rating system is a sham. It is always possible to do better and always possible to do worse.

[/ QUOTE ]

To harsh, Perfect is 80% completion and a TD or two (there'a a huge formula, but that performance should get you 158.3) I believe. That seems like a fair appraisal.

Cody

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
9/11 218 yds. 2TD/0INT

lol @ Roethlisbergers first perfecto. WTF is this??? QB rating is soooo stupid. And what about when you throw a 10 yard slant and someone runs 70 yards for the TD? This system makes you look so much better because of WR YAC.

[/ QUOTE ]

No question, is a good metric, not a perfect one. It's a solid system but it's not the end-all-to-be-all.

Cody

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Perfect is 80% completion

[/ QUOTE ]

see the problem with that? [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
49.40476190476189

Edited for ridiculously unnecessary accuracy, so that my post adds something despite being second [img]/images/graemlins/wink.gif[/img]

Cool site

[/ QUOTE ]

Awesome site, thanks for posting. I used to calculate Jason Campbell's rating by hand after each game. No more.

P.S. He had a 145.2 yesterday and we LOST! McNabb's was 158.3.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Some people in this forum seriously need to learn why stats are used - to be applied, not as strict dogma.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
49.40476190476189

Edited for ridiculously unnecessary accuracy, so that my post adds something despite being second [img]/images/graemlins/wink.gif[/img]

Cool site

[/ QUOTE ]

Awesome site, thanks for posting. I used to calculate Jason Campbell's rating by hand after each game. No more.

P.S. He had a 145.2 yesterday and we LOST! McNabb's was 158.3.

[/ QUOTE ]

You calculated wrong (you enter attempts first, not completions).

McNabb had a 138.54166666666669 yesterday and Campbell had a 114.21568627450982

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Hijack....

Since there is no "perfect game", what is the best single game any QB has ever played in everyone's opinion?


99,970 and counting

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Hijack....

Since there is no "perfect game", what is the best single game any QB has ever played in everyone's opinion?


99,970 and counting

[/ QUOTE ]
If you want to differentiate between the various NFL perfect games, you can try putting them into the college rating system, which has a much wider range. Perfection in the college system is every attempt being a 99 yard TD pass, which has only been done by Peyton Manning, Mike Vick and Vince Young.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
49.40476190476189

Edited for ridiculously unnecessary accuracy, so that my post adds something despite being second [img]/images/graemlins/wink.gif[/img]

Cool site

[/ QUOTE ]

Awesome site, thanks for posting. I used to calculate Jason Campbell's rating by hand after each game. No more.

P.S. He had a 145.2 yesterday and we LOST! McNabb's was 158.3.

[/ QUOTE ]

You calculated wrong (you enter attempts first, not completions).

McNabb had a 138.54166666666669 yesterday and Campbell had a 114.21568627450982



[/ QUOTE ]

Oh right. Thanks.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]

You calculated wrong (you enter attempts first, not completions).

[/ QUOTE ]
I do that almost every time I use that site. Its very counterintuitive.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Brady has 3 rings and Manning has 1. Brady hasnt had good receivers until this yr. Brady is better than Manning even be4 yesterday's game anyway hands down.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Odd to see Peyton Manning and Jon Kitna both have bad games on the same day. Was there a full moon last night?