Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

My friends finally convinced me to sit down and watch Reservoir Dogs yesterday. I really like Pulp Fiction and went in with high hopes for Reservoir Dogs. I was definitely satisfied with the movie. A lot of what is great in Pulp Fiction is present in Reservoir Dogs (great soundtrack, long detailed scenes, memorable characters, and scenes that are just awesome). That said, I still think Pulp Fiction is considerably better (more awesome scenes).

What do you think?

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

First.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Pulp Fiction obv

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

yeah pulp fiction definitely has "more awesome scenes" since both movies are awesome and pulp fiction is like twice as long.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

I like reservoir dogs better, but that's partly because everyone loves pulp fiction and I'm a rebel

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Reservoir Dogs is awesome, Pulp Fiction is BAD-ASS

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Reservoir Dogs is a great movie but Pulp Fiction has so much more going on. I love both flicks but Pulp Fiction easily takes it down HU.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Script writing even better in PF, though, hard to think of a single scene (outside the Bruce willis return with samurai sword to redneck basement) that matchs the pureness of the ear interogation scene in RD.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Movies aren't real.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

I think it's close, but I guess Pulp Fiction is probably a bit better. The ear-cutting-off scene in Res Dogs is classic awesomeness though, along with some of the great one-liners...

"you shoot me in a dream, you better wake up and apologize"

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

pulp fiction was better. Both were very good, both are very overrated.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

PF wins for me because the chemistry between SLJ & JT was just not there in dogs.

Also, PF is the only documented case of a white guy using the 'N' word with spectacular success.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

I used to think Reservoir Dogs >>> Pulp Fiction and it wasn't close, but now it's definitely closer.

Bruce Willis with French girl scenes just tilt the [censored] out of me though.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

http://i215.photobucket.com/albums/c...ckinwityou.jpg

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

I don't think Buddy Holly is much of a waiter.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

They are both really good movies. Pulp Fiction wins because of all the different scenes and locations. It also wins cuz it made John Travolta a gangsta.


Conspire

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[x] That is a tasty burger

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Also, what is everyone's favorite scene in each movie?

for me:

Reservoir Dogs: Stuck in the Middle With You
Pulp Fiction: diner scene at end

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
Also, what is everyone's favorite scene in each movie?

[/ QUOTE ]

reservoir dogs: "so you go to the train station to pick up the buyer..with the weed on ya?" that whole little mini scene where he's telling them that fake anecdote.

pulp fiction: the OD / adrenaline shot scene.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Pulp Fiction wins overall, but Reservoir Dogs has better dialogue imo

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Quentin Tarantino is way overrated imo.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

"God damn, thats a pretty [censored]' good milkshake."

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Joe: "So, you guys like to tell jokes, huh? Gigglin' and laughin' like a bunch of young broads sittin' in a schoolyard. Well, let me tell a joke. Five guys, sittin' in a bullpen, in San Quentin. All wondering how the [censored] they got there. What should we have done, what didn't we do, who's fault is it, is it my fault, your fault, his fault, all that [censored]. Then one of them says, hey. Wait a minute. When we were planning this caper, all we did was sit around tellin' [censored]' jokes!"

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

I'd choose Pulp Fiction, and by a pretty good margin, too.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

I thought True Romance was pretty good.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Reservoir Dogs is a draft... Pulp Fiction is the good copy

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
I thought True Lies was pretty good.

[/ QUOTE ]

fyp

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Nobody else thinks Tarantino is an a-hole?

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
Nobody else thinks Tarantino is an a-hole?

[/ QUOTE ]

How is that relevant to the discussion?

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

http://hitchcock.tv/people/img/tarantinop2.jpg

he always has this smug, condescending look on his face as if he knows something you dont. seems like an a-hole imo.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Nobody else thinks Tarantino is an a-hole?

[/ QUOTE ]

How is that relevant to the discussion?

[/ QUOTE ]

Because the movies are just OK imo but are people want to praise them like they are greatest films ever made and call Tarantino a genius and stuff like that, and its annoying.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Yes, I said they are just ok. Go ahead, flame away.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

never seen pulp fiction afaik

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

The one where Uma Thurman was a ninja sucked.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
The one where Uma Thurman was a ninja sucked.

[/ QUOTE ]

both of them did imo

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

Ive seen QT at drai's with about 15 hookers around him. He must be doing something right...

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
Ive seen QT at drai's with about 15 hookers around him. He must be doing something right...

[/ QUOTE ]

yeah, he has a lot of money... so what?

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
http://hitchcock.tv/people/img/tarantinop2.jpg

he always has this smug, condescending look on his face as if he knows something you dont. seems like a rolemodel imo.

[/ QUOTE ]

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
The one where Uma Thurman was a ninja sucked.

[/ QUOTE ]

both of them did imo

[/ QUOTE ]

But, come on, Uuuuummmmmmmaaaah! She is freaking hot in these.

Re: Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs
 

[ QUOTE ]
http://hitchcock.tv/people/img/tarantinop2.jpg

he always has this smug, condescending look on his face as if he knows something you dont. seems like an a-hole imo.

[/ QUOTE ]

He's not making that face on purpose, he is just ugly.