Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

i can only answer this question since it was the night i took over as geran

[ QUOTE ]
Why did they kill OH?

[/ QUOTE ]

i felt that a) OH was a powerrole, not necessarily seer, b) spook was also a powerrole, possibly seer, and c) that night protection would be used on spook. i figured take a guaranteed power role out and let them waste their protection.

while the bad guys ran bad (i.e. after my day 1 shenanigans i'm the one that ends up being geran, gg), the wolves before me (namely chuck/shorty/nich) played absolutely horribly.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

also, we knew who liselle was the day madtown came out because we knew madtown as cyradis. i can't speak for tabako/mornelth, but they probably wanted to keep the village guessing and that it was worth the risk of a 1/3 peek.

imo, nothing completely wrong w/ that. killing IY instead though is probably pretty bad

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

Did you know that Madtown was neutral when luckay made that announcement, or did you simply know that he was non-evil?

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

the N1 kill was madtown, so we knew he was cyradis. we knew every role except for liselle the day before i died

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

Awesome work Jared and VR, 2nd great game in a row

I agree that the game was very pro neutral, village played great and ran great to overcome that.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]
the N1 kill was madtown, so we knew he was cyradis. we knew every role except for liselle the day before i died

[/ QUOTE ]

I am dumb.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]
also, we knew who liselle was the day madtown came out because we knew madtown as cyradis. i can't speak for tabako/mornelth, but they probably wanted to keep the village guessing and that it was worth the risk of a 1/3 peek.

imo, nothing completely wrong w/ that. killing IY instead though is probably pretty bad

[/ QUOTE ]

Late in the game, Madtown decided to gamble. He sent a message to evils not to kill Soah. He was hoping that with him being alive, enough villagers could be convinced to lynch him. Not sure if it was a good gamble, but they were clearly in pretty bad shape. If Soah had gotten lynched in there then neutrals would have been in pretty good shape.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

also, me playing out as cyradis was the only way we could have possibly had a chance at winning

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

JaredL,

As I told you before the demon power is broken. If Nich had correctly saved it until after the seer was dead, it would have been much more devastating. The expected number of dead villagers that power is worth is 3, which is way too many combined with everything else the evils have going for them imo.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

we only whiffed 2 lynches and we had to win multiple coinflips (well the last night should have been one)