Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

i love people who say a player is better than another based on one single game performance...every player will have a bad game now and then, it doesnt matter who you are

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

FWIW, list of games with perfect QB ratings. Peyton has 4.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_qua..._passer_rating

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
FWIW, list of games with perfect QB ratings. Peyton has 4.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_qua..._passer_rating

[/ QUOTE ]

Only cause of his great Wide outs, LDO.

Cody

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
FWIW, list of games with perfect QB ratings. Peyton has 4.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_qua..._passer_rating

[/ QUOTE ]

How the hell does Kerry Collins make that list and not Phil Simms during SB XXI? If that doesn't tell you there's something wrong w/ the ratings system, I don't know what does.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

Whats wrong with the rating system is you can have a "perfect" game and still throw incompletions. That's not "perfect" imo. The qb rating system is a sham. It is always possible to do better and always possible to do worse.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
FWIW, list of games with perfect QB ratings. Peyton has 4.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_qua..._passer_rating

[/ QUOTE ]

How the hell does Kerry Collins make that list and not Phil Simms during SB XXI? If that doesn't tell you there's something wrong w/ the ratings system, I don't know what does.

[/ QUOTE ]

Simms was 8 points away.

FWIW, that game Collins played was pretty awesome - I definitely remember it. The Giants successfully executed an 80+ yard flea flicker.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
FWIW, that game Collins played was pretty awesome - I definitely remember it. The Giants successfully executed an 80+ yard flea flicker.

[/ QUOTE ]

I remember that game. The flea-flicker was on the first play of the second half. Real back-breaker.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

9/11 218 yds. 2TD/0INT

lol @ Roethlisbergers first perfecto. WTF is this??? QB rating is soooo stupid. And what about when you throw a 10 yard slant and someone runs 70 yards for the TD? This system makes you look so much better because of WR YAC.

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Whats wrong with the rating system is you can have a "perfect" game and still throw incompletions. That's not "perfect" imo. The qb rating system is a sham. It is always possible to do better and always possible to do worse.

[/ QUOTE ]

To harsh, Perfect is 80% completion and a TD or two (there'a a huge formula, but that performance should get you 158.3) I believe. That seems like a fair appraisal.

Cody

Re: What was Manning\'s QB rating tonight?
 

[ QUOTE ]
9/11 218 yds. 2TD/0INT

lol @ Roethlisbergers first perfecto. WTF is this??? QB rating is soooo stupid. And what about when you throw a 10 yard slant and someone runs 70 yards for the TD? This system makes you look so much better because of WR YAC.

[/ QUOTE ]

No question, is a good metric, not a perfect one. It's a solid system but it's not the end-all-to-be-all.

Cody