Re: JC Tran controversy poll
 

[ QUOTE ]
I'm fully away what the rule is in donkaments. The point is, its ability to prevent collusion is NOT effective enough to warrant overlooking these types of scenarios, such as the JC Tran video. This situation happens more than you're aware of i think.....

[/ QUOTE ]

Name three other instances where this has happened, ever.

Re: JC Tran controversy poll
 

Looks like the rule is winning in the poll. Maybe you should rephrase the question though since it is clearly biased towards the current rule. I don't think that you are giving the "If a player folds their hand, for sake of tilt or any reason, they are held accountable by losing their right to win the pot, no showdown, hand is over....cards speak, just DONT do it" a fair chance.... maybe put it in bold and capitalize it or something.

Re: JC Tran controversy poll
 

not by much, which is the point

Re: JC Tran controversy poll
 

[ QUOTE ]
not by much, which is the point

[/ QUOTE ]

Even with the biased phrasing your opinion is losing in the poll.

New poll
 

Re: New poll
 

Am I the only one seeing OP 40 years in the future, with his grandchildren on knee, telling them all the story of THE HAND - the hand where someone else called villains straight flush and cost him a huge pot.

Re: New poll
 

[ QUOTE ]
The only thing I'm "listening" to is the poll #s.

[/ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Looks like the rule is winning in the poll.

[/ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
not by much, which is the point

[/ QUOTE ]

So i guess you're not really listening to the pole if it doesn't get the results you want.

Re: JC Tran controversy poll
 

[ QUOTE ]
nice unbiased, neutral framing of the question there lol

[/ QUOTE ]

As someone who works with many Ph. D scientists designing survey questions and stuff I can honestly say this is one of the most heavily biased polls in terms of wording I have ever seen.

Re: JC Tran controversy poll
 

[ QUOTE ]
so that we will never see another player awkwardly pulling back their cards from the muck and simultaneously jamming their chips in the pot

[/ QUOTE ]

this isnt what happened. his chips clearly were in the pot prior to his attempted much. like way before.

Re: JC Tran controversy poll
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
so that we will never see another player awkwardly pulling back their cards from the muck and simultaneously jamming their chips in the pot

[/ QUOTE ]

this isnt what happened. his chips clearly were in the pot prior to his attempted much. like way before.

[/ QUOTE ]

Doesnt it show the guy putting his own chips in front of JC's chips as if he is GIVING him the chips? I could be wrong, thats just how I remember it.