Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]
sighing,

you have to consider that mengha could be bobo. or tokyo. or dmk, or luckay or trufloridagator.

[/ QUOTE ]
This is true.. and frightening, since I tend to work off the assumption that people play in a way I understand.

But I suspect if it was bobo he would've started yesterday.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]
zurvan,

they wouldn't be trading mengha for the seer if they've found the seer already...

[/ QUOTE ]

If they kill him with mengha after finding him last night?

Maybe they wanted to try & take out the seer before he was able to announce his peeks.

I agree it's unlikely, but not impossible

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
all,

as to sighings defense... please consider that if mengha refused to target anyone at all who was possibly a seer, he might have very few targets. on top of that, there are two scenarios:

1. evil seer saw good seer already, they knew wdc wasn't it.
2. evils don't mind trading mengha for good seer.

[/ QUOTE ]
It's not really a trade.. It's a risk. If the evils saw the good seer, would they be worried enough about their win chances to risk Mengha on Day 2?

[/ QUOTE ]

If they saw the good seer last night, are you saying we used our one time angel power last night? Why wouldn't the seer be dead right now?

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
zurvan,

they wouldn't be trading mengha for the seer if they've found the seer already...

[/ QUOTE ]

If they kill him with mengha after finding him last night?

Maybe they wanted to try & take out the seer before he was able to announce his peeks.

I agree it's unlikely, but not impossible

[/ QUOTE ]
Zurvan, if Mengha attacks the seer, Mengha automatically dies and the seer doesn't.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]


Zurvan, if Mengha attacks the seer, Mengha automatically dies and the seer doesn't.

[/ QUOTE ]

OK, I totally misread one of your posts.

And by mis-read, I mean, you said that they'd be trading mengha for the seer.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

zurvan, house, luckay, please answer my question. thx.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

***DEAD***

ZOMG and WTF!

***DEAD***

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]


Zurvan, if Mengha attacks the seer, Mengha automatically dies and the seer doesn't.

[/ QUOTE ]

OK, I totally misread one of your posts.

And by mis-read, I mean, you said that they'd be trading mengha for the seer.

[/ QUOTE ]
Actually Xorbie said that, and I replied that it wasn't a trade...

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]


Zurvan, if Mengha attacks the seer, Mengha automatically dies and the seer doesn't.

[/ QUOTE ]

OK, I totally misread one of your posts.

And by mis-read, I mean, you said that they'd be trading mengha for the seer.

[/ QUOTE ]

that's what i said, and i meant in the sense that if mengha targeted wdc and mengha died, they know wdc is seer and kill him that night.

Re: The Malloreon: GAME THREAD and FINAL ROLE DESCRIPTIONS
 

[ QUOTE ]

that's what i said, and i meant in the sense that if mengha targeted wdc and mengha died, they know wdc is seer and kill him that night.

[/ QUOTE ]

OK, I got confused, sorry for confusing everybody else.

One problem - mengha selects 3 targets, and one dies at random. So, they really are narrowing down the seer possibilities, not getting it for sure.