LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
ok. Has been shorter than what I feared.

traz : obvious on first glance. Less obious on the second glance. Still a question mark.
Neil : am I the only one to find him wolfy ? I was villager on my first game, but would I've been a wolf, I would have had play it exactly this way. Question mark.
fmxda : actions coherent for a wolf. I'm a bride player. We call this a percentage play.

Other question marks : VR ? IY ? Nez ? Stephen ? Luckay ?
from the most wolfiest to the least..

For the moment being, [bfmxda[/b]

[/ QUOTE ]

My translation:
traz: my wolf buddy, please don't kill him so a seer can clear him
neil: please get interested in voting this villager off
fmxda: i know he's a villager, but i'll vote him off anyways

other wolf list with probably 1 wolf in the list: VR IY Nez Stephen Luckay (I currently suspect Nez is the wolf on this list; it's right in the middle)

---

Yea, I'm still pretty comfortable with a Voj vote.

[sighing]

[ 3 ] aaronk
[ 4 ] clowntable voted for econophile
[ 0 ] dmk voted for clowntable
[ 1 ] econophile voted for aaronk
[ 0 ] GT1T voted for stephen
[ 1 ] Iron_Yuppie
[ 0 ] jeremy
[ 0 ] kumubou
[ 0 ] lastchance voted for voj
[ 0 ] luckay voted for stephen
[ 0 ] Neil Stevens voted for stephen
[ 0 ] nez voted for aaronk
[ 0 ] nichp voted for voj
[ 0 ] soah voted for stephen
[ 4 ] stephen voted for voj
[ 0 ] thebram voted for Iron_Yuppie
[ 0 ] traz voted for aaronk
[ 3 ] voj
[ 0 ] VR voted for clowntable
[ 0 ] xorbie voted for clowntable
[ 0 ] zurvan voted for clowntable

[Stephen H]

Alright, I'm caught up and here's my current list:

Wolves:
nez
voj
traz
dmk
econophile (weakest read; others are in no order)

Village:
clown
aaron
zurvan
kumu
neil
lastc
gt1t

not enough info/no read:
soah
bram
vr
xorbie

conflicting reads/wtf list:
IY
Jeremy
luckay (surprised he's on this list? me either - i'm leaning village though)

Claiming Frodo:
Nichp

I think that's everyone. It's entirely possible this whole list goes to crap if voj isn't a wolf.

[Jeremy517]

[ QUOTE ]
Also this made me think jeremy is wolfish because he didn't switch off me onto one of the wagons "because it would look bad". I don't know off the top of my had if he was one of the first on me but if he was then this is interesting.

Only have to figure out if his explaination is belivable or not. That's why I asked again [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]


[/ QUOTE ]

If you read other game threads (such as Election and Dungeon as a seer, and No Information as a wolf), you will see me reference my commute. Regardless of my role in any WW game, there will be times when my commute keeps me away when night falls. This wasn't the first game where that happens, and it won't be the last.

[Voj]

Hey Stephen that's funny how I really disagree with your list.
StephenH for the moment.
I'll be hanging till 4am GMT this time so I may change my vote

[Stephen H]

Voj: Yea, not really surprising.
I'd be a lot more interested in hearing what people on my villager list think of the list.

Everyone, if I get lynched today, PLEASE reconsider my list after I'm dead. DO NOT let traz slide by, even with a seer peek, if Voj is a wolf (and maybe even if he isn't)

[Voj]

[ QUOTE ]
It's entirely possible this whole list goes to crap if voj isn't a wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]

Ok. Pls don't waste time and make an another list taking account (let's say it's an intellectual challenge since you're absolutely convinced I'm a wolf and I'm getting the feeling you're not gonna change your mind about it) the fact that I'm a villager.

I would be seriously intertested in that (and that may change my vote) since if I obviouosly disagree with me being a wolf ; I also disagree with most of your list.

[Nez477]

I'm going to say this one more time and not mention it again.

I messed up voting for GT1T d1. That is all. I am not the wolf that switched votes, likely Aaron or IY are. If I get lynched I guess I deserve it for being a moron, but I wouldn't have pushed TFG so hard all day and then give up at 8:45 as a wolf. It makes no sense, I'm just a dumb villager.

Let's vote Aaron, it's a hot lynch today I think.

[aaronk56]

[ QUOTE ]
Alright, I'm caught up and here's my current list:

Wolves:
nez
voj
traz
dmk
econophile (weakest read; others are in no order)

Village:
clown
aaron
zurvan
kumu
neil
lastc
gt1t

not enough info/no read:
soah
bram
vr
xorbie

conflicting reads/wtf list:
IY
Jeremy
luckay (surprised he's on this list? me either - i'm leaning village though)

Claiming Frodo:
Nichp

I think that's everyone. It's entirely possible this whole list goes to crap if voj isn't a wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think your list is pretty good. The only villager on your list I question is lastchance, I'm suspicious of him. I can see Nez, econ and voj being wolves. Traz maybe especially if he has the godfather role because he could make a play like he did the first day. I still don't know why he would want to start another bandwagon that day unless we were voting all wolves. Dmk I think is a villager.

My biggest problem with your list is that I could see you and nez both being wolves. The way Nez has come after me, it reminds of you as a wolf in a game about 6 - 7 months ago. You just came out hammering me for being evil. I wasn't, you were but you got me lynched. Did you suggest that strategy to Nez or am I paranoid?

On a different note, I think that Amp was the target not Herbie. If we lynch Nez and he turns up a wolf, I'll be nearly 100% sure of it.

[Jeremy517]

[ QUOTE ]
On a different note, I think that Amp was the target not Herbie. If we lynch Nez and he turns up a wolf, I'll be nearly 100% sure of it.

[/ QUOTE ]

OK, this is more than a little suspicious to me. If Amp was the target, it would possibly look bad on YOU, not just Nez. The last person that Amp voted for before joining the fmxda wagon wasn't Nez, it was you.

It makes it look like it was a seer hunt because he named you, and now you're trying to deflect suspicion onto someone else.