Election! - The Game Thread

[HerbieGRD]

Soah - your argument about Bluff is convincing and well reasoned. I would add to it that on day one of Mallorean he managed to go all day without accusing anyone of being wolfy or making a wolfy post. He was a wolf

Books - I am totally split on how the assassin should proceed in this game - I just have no idea whether it would be better for him to fire every chance he gets or wait until legacies can be passed down. Both options have merit but I am leaning towards him not shooting, for a little while at least, being the better plan.

Chim - do you see the flaw in your "wolves just pass the legacy to wolves" theory? Soah says you always sound wolfy so I won't be too quick to pass judgment (but you do sound wolfy to me)

[traz]

To stimulate discussion and to help guide those who feel lost, i'm going to post my current list. Assassin, feel free to use this as your basis :P

With such a gigantic field, and so many people posting useless posts yesterday, its obviously super preliminary and is likely to change substantially. I can't really call anyone wolves right now, but that'll change soon as well.

villagers:
Fnord
Herbie
Soah
traz
bram

leaning villager:
wdc
boiler
cpfb
Valenzuela
Econophile
Spook
Luckay
Mdd
Aaron
clown

players to watch:
chim
fmxda
chuckles
voj
amplify
scotthoward
Iron

players to REALLY watch:
mets
shortline
IY
Jeremy
Fcbl
Bluff
dmk
lc
xorbie

[traz]

and with that, I'll bbiab

[xorbie]

so if bluff's a wolf maybe iron is a wolf too. that last post by bluff's not helping his case.

also forgot to add lastchance to my list. at first i thought his mass role claim strat was just a lame angle shoot type idea, but if you look at the rest of his posts they are downright terrible, would help the evils greatly (assassin coming out wtf). also a few other posts that i'm too lazy to find again.

[xorbie]

if you take me and fcbl off that list, i likes it.

[chim17]

Herbie,

Yes of course a wolf can't just pass 100%. However, it doesn't necessarily mean the player they pass to is a villager.

My whole point was keeping a wolf alive for legacy reasons is bad strategy. I can't see how that is beneficial. Clearly, if you are unsure you should wait. But I do not like the idea of "xxx is a wolf, lets wait to kill him!"

[ScottHoward]

[ QUOTE ]
Scott, that was not an error. I had a reason for liking a jeremy lynch last night more than a boiler lynch

[/ QUOTE ]
no? maybe i misread then.
[ QUOTE ]
Ok, I think exactly one of the bram, zurv, boiler is a wolf. My order of preference for voting someone off right now is the bram, distant second jeremy (but I would really have to go back and re read before I felt comfortable about this), distantly followed by zurvan.

[/ QUOTE ]
you say one of bram, zurv, boiler is a wolf, and in the next sentence you give a lynch order of bram, jeremy, zurvan. how did jeremy pop in there?

[fnord_too]

Here's my spreadsheet sans notes. It shows who is eligible to be elected at the dirrent intervals (X in the left most can be elected any time, X in the next column can be elected days 2 and 3) I think it is correct. On the right is a little score card of roles.

[MDoranD]

Chim,

Other wolf suspects include:
-Boiler
-Jeremy
-Iron

I would not be against any of those being lynched.

-------------

Thebram,

I am not faking seer as I dont do that as a villager. If I am wrong about you then people will have to either deal with me accordingly in their eyes or believe that my intentions were good. You made a post yesterday that rang bells big time to me. One of the posts you made today was almost as bad.

WDC,

I really think you would think more before making that post if you were a villager.

[soah]

[ QUOTE ]
Soah - your argument about Bluff is convincing and well reasoned. I would add to it that on day one of Mallorean he managed to go all day without accusing anyone of being wolfy or making a wolfy post. He was a wolf

[/ QUOTE ]

yeah, I meant to illustrate that him calling ppl out for making wolfy posts is something I've seen him do routinely as a villager (on the rare occasion that he has been one) but not when he's a wolf. I just forgot to include the other stuff