**American Idol Finals: Classic Love Songs

[Soul Daddy]

That was a great performance by Chris. And I'm not just saying that because at least 5 people a day tell me that I look like him.

[Brocktoon]

I honestly think the judges are basically told in no uncertain terms that the last performance is to receive positive feedback only and the move over the top the better. Its literally EVERY week. It cannot be coincidence.

[BarronVangorToth]

Tonight's Ranking:

1st: Elliott
2nd: Chris
3rd: Paris
4th: Taylor
5th: Katharine
6th: Kellie

My personal thoughts on tonight aren't going to mean much as Kellie nor Taylor have ever been in the bottom 3 ... and despite being two of the three worst tonight, I'm not sure that's going to change this week.

It's a really hard week to call, especially since Elliott did so well.

[ajmargarine]

He looks in, he's got the sign. Comes set. Daughtry waits. The windup, and the pitch. Swing, long drive, deep left field. It could be...It might be...IT IS. A Home Run. Holy Cow.

They really rigged it for Chris with the onstage guitarists and going last, but Chris was very very very goot tonite.

[TStoneMBD]

chris' performance was worse than the original version. hes not better than that random bum who sang it the first time. katherine held her own on a whitney song, thats FAR more impressive than that [censored].

[splashpot]

[ QUOTE ]
He looks in, he's got the sign. Comes set. Daughtry waits. The windup, and the pitch. Swing, long drive, deep left field. It could be...It might be...IT IS. A Home Run. Holy Cow.

[/ QUOTE ]
Dude, this is really gay.

[Soul Daddy]

[ QUOTE ]
They really rigged it for Chris with the onstage guitarists and going last, but Chris was very very very goot tonite.

[/ QUOTE ]
Yeah. Methinks the Idol folks were none too happy that he was in the bottom two last week.

[primetime32]

Elliot is by far the most overrated AI performer of all time. But for whatever reason the judges are going to jerk him off everytime he performs. Everyone i watched the show with thought kat, taylor and chris were better.

just because kat didnt perform the song as well as whitney doesnt make her performance any less great. The judgs always make that mistake.

bottom 3 this week will be elliot, paris and probably kat because she went first and was killed by the judges. I would have guessed kellie but she seems immune from the bottom 3 these days.

[Hornacek]

Are we sure its bottom 3 this week, and not Bottom 2?

[krazyace5]

[ QUOTE ]
fat paula needs to take her midol definitely

and i think randy is right more often than simon

[/ QUOTE ]

Randy is almost as pathetic as Paula. Simon rules.