LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[econophile]

i can go with iron yuppie

or possibly fmxda

[aaronk56]

I don't know what to make of Nez. Yesterday he spends most of the time hammering on TFG as evil, except for a brief period of time where he feels sorry for himself because he's getting some heat, but after being so sure of TFG all day, he switches off of him at 9:53 and votes GT1T. I'll ask you the question you asked me. Why Nez?

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Ok, i'm now 90% sure Traz is for the good in this game. let's check other options. VR, Stephen and AARON are great lynches.

[/ QUOTE ]

I am not a great lynch.

Nez, Voj, and fmxda are great lynches.

See, I can do it too.

[/ QUOTE ]

Good for you.

I'm not just pulling needles from a haystack, did you even read my post? I have reasons for each.

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
I don't know what to make of Nez. Yesterday he spends most of the time hammering on TFG as evil, except for a brief period of time where he feels sorry for himself because he's getting some heat, but after being so sure of TFG all day, he switches off of him at 9:53 and votes GT1T. I'll ask you the question you asked me. Why Nez?

[/ QUOTE ]

Aaron, please answer my previous question.

Trust me, I'm pissed I switched. I had such a read, then he made a villagery excuse late and I was more interested in 30 Rock and was looking at my other game too... just was dumb.

TFG was my read from the start and I goofed at the end of the night, that's all.

[Nez477]

Nevermind, saw you answered my question.

I don't want to change from Aaron today people, let's move.

[clowntable]

IY starts the wagon on GT1T. Noone follows for a while.

traz votes
[ QUOTE ]
lastchance

go wagon go!

[/ QUOTE ]

iy votes
[ QUOTE ]
I like a lastchance vote.

[/ QUOTE ]

traz posts
[ QUOTE ]
ok. since no one is with me on lc, who will vote gt1t with me?

[/ QUOTE ]

GT1T picks up steam, IY votes
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
ok. since no one is with me on lc, who will vote gt1t with me?

[/ QUOTE ]

hmmmm, gt1t you say? Interesting.....

GT1T

[/ QUOTE ]
(making it sound like omg, it's all traz' plan)

So it's not so unlikely that IY=wolf; traz=scapegoat.

What bothers me is that my wagon never took off and especially why traz didn't vote me. I have to think about this for a while.

[traz]

I already said that being forced to pick you and gt1t, I thought gt1t was wolfier

[traz]

Also, I was going to comment on IY following me around like a lapdog, but I thought it was too obvious for IY-wolf

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
vote stephen

I have a hard time believing that traz would do that as a wolf. And by "that" I mean:

* specifically state that his intention is to save TFG
* try to push everyone onto a brand new wagon while running out of time instead of picking someone that already had votes

the wolves on the gt1t wagon will be the ones that did it quietly. they want traz to be their lightning rod when things go bad.

[/ QUOTE ]

i agree that stephen sounds kinda wolfy, but don't you think he would have voted for GT1T to save TFG

[/ QUOTE ]
His whole reason for suspecting you was that you + TFG are both wolves. If he votes GT1T last night it basically announces to the thread that he and TFG are both wolves. He wouldn't ever vote GT1T there as a wolf

[VoraciousReader]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Ok, i'm now 90% sure Traz is for the good in this game. let's check other options. VR, Stephen and AARON are great lynches.

[/ QUOTE ]

I am not a great lynch.

Nez, Voj, and fmxda are great lynches.

See, I can do it too.

[/ QUOTE ]

Good for you.

I'm not just pulling needles from a haystack, did you even read my post? I have reasons for each.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes. I read your post. As I recall, your reason for me was TFG mentioned my name. That makes me a "great" lynch?

How about this:

2 wagons: 1 evil power role, and 1 on Voj. Instead of the wolves piling votes on Voj, somehow a 3rd wagon gets going on Stephen H.

1 person, hammers hard on lynching TFG all day, yet somehow, switches right before deadline. Who could that be? Oh, right, you.

1 person pops up out of nowhere to put a super late vote on GT1T with no explanation. Who's that?
Oh, right, fmxda.

1 person who could possibly manage to shift a bandwagon all by himself and is likely to get peeked early anyway vehemently defends TFG. Who's that? traz. (who I don't personally think is evil, but I certainly understand people wanting to kill him.

And yet, according to you, the "great lynches" are: StephenH, who was apparently put forward as the competing wagon over Voj; aaronk, who hasn't done much this game except suspect me, and me, who didn't even manage to vote for gt or tfg in what turned out to be a critical lynch.

The fact that those three made your "lynch" list and none of the others did boggles the mind (I understand why you left yourself off, of course.)

Voting Nez