***Official Top 9 Show Thread***

[Soul Daddy]

Paula says Phil reminds him of a young Frank Sinatra. I think I look forward to her comments more than anything on this show.

[4Tay]

Goodbye Phil!

[odellthurman]

Phil is sweating like a whore in Church.

[easternbloc]

[ QUOTE ]
Paula says Phil reminds him of a young Frank Sinatra. I think I look forward to her comments more than anything on this show.

[/ QUOTE ]

she's the sanjaya of judges. I enjoy them both for their ridiculousness.

[thing85]

There's a very good chance Phil is gone this week...


Why are the good contestants going early?

[Russ M.]

I am so sick of Shrek acting shocked about anything complementary. Enough already.

[easternbloc]

doolittle really isn't impressing me this week.


edit: okay, the way she ended the song was good.

[Suiteness]

Damn she's good.

[Shrug]

Wish Melinda could sing " I've Got a Neck"

[thing85]

Melinda's got a pretty dynamic performance tonight. Good mix showing her strengths with various tempos.