CYOA: Toria-ran Keep

[Mark_K]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
As an aside, I have become convinced that the most effective defense in almost all cases is to keep your mouth shut.

[/ QUOTE ]

Are you hinting at something to me books, or just making an observation?

[/ QUOTE ]
And this is pretty much why.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes, a very interesting post by Kbar... But wouldn't a wolf who already made one "slip-up" (The "Yes" comment)really try to avoid a second? (Granted the later Seer Claim Slip was at a point of desperation)

BTW, It is interesting that Books is taking his own advice today and lying low....

[metsandfinsfan]

[ QUOTE ]
Kbar wanted bluff lynched. Kbar was trying hard to get bluff lynched. Kbar was disappointed when bluff was not lynched. Feels way more like a villager push than a wolf push, yo.

[/ QUOTE ]

Lastchance: If you were a power wolf --- would you think it was worth it to fake seer and get a regular wolf killed instead of you? So that would clear you and you were certain you would be alive several days. You do it late at night so there is not much time for people to verify your claim. People switch off you and onto bluff. Then two astute villagers notice the error in your seer claim. And the plan fails

You would not be genuinely disappointed?

Again: if you guys want to give bluff some slack today, i am fine with that. But stop saying he is a clear villager

[BluffBlank]

I'm good with a dustin vote. I really can't find anything that changes my list from before. I've reread last night 2 or 3 times and not come up with anything.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Kbar wanted bluff lynched. Kbar was trying hard to get bluff lynched. Kbar was disappointed when bluff was not lynched. Feels way more like a villager push than a wolf push, yo.

[/ QUOTE ]

Lastchance: If you were a power wolf --- would you think it was worth it to fake seer and get a regular wolf killed instead of you? So that would clear you and you were certain you would be alive several days. You do it late at night so there is not much time for people to verify your claim. People switch off you and onto bluff. Then two astute villagers notice the error in your seer claim. And the plan fails

You would not be genuinely disappointed?

Again: if you guys want to give bluff some slack today, i am fine with that. But stop saying he is a clear villager

[/ QUOTE ]
No. Simply put, no. I metagame, hell yes. But 1) Kbar sucks at wolfing. 2) It's a huge mistake to do what he did (if bluff is a regular wolf) unless he has huge amounts of powers (and I don't think he did). In fact, I probably deliberately screw up my seer claim so I get pwned instead of bluff (this would be genius, but I don't respect kbar's wolf game enough).

Getting another wolf lynched when you know you're going to get lynched before endgame sucks. I don't think bluff was a wolf push.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]

Yes, a very interesting post by Kbar... But wouldn't a wolf who already made one "slip-up" (The "Yes" comment)really try to avoid a second? (Granted the later Seer Claim Slip was at a point of desperation)

BTW, It is interesting that Books is taking his own advice today and lying low....

[/ QUOTE ]
Kbar is not a good wolf. Kbar is a bad one. Let us assume that, please.

[chuckleslovakian]

List

Villager:
Chuck
Mets
MDD
Mark
Madtown
Books
Lastchance

Meh
Jeremy517
Kumubou
Luckay
Traz

Wolfy:
Dustin

[metsandfinsfan]

assasin is pretty powerful. He poisoned shortline and may have had more poison or was on his way to more poison. Poising a villager every 3 or 4 days in addition to the night kills is pretty damn powerful

[ QUOTE ]
No. Simply put, no. I metagame, hell yes. But 1) Kbar sucks at wolfing. 2) It's a huge mistake to do what he did (if bluff is a regular wolf) unless he has huge amounts of powers (and I don't think he did). In fact, I probably deliberately screw up my seer claim so I get pwned instead of bluff (this would be genius, but I don't respect kbar's wolf game enough).

[/ QUOTE ]

i dont believe you here. I'll drop it for now but im telling you i dont believe you

[Mark_K]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
damn you IY

[/ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
gg guys

Let me just say that I hate my boss for basically standing over me the entire day while I was trying to post.

lynch my boss

[/ QUOTE ]
Without these posts, I would not "clear" bluff as much as I have. But considering those seemingly genuine posts above, I cannot imagine voting bluff off in the near future.

[/ QUOTE ]

BTW, I wonder who Kbar means by "Boss" in this above quote?
Is it his work boss OOORRRR is he referring to WDCBooks?????

His boss "standing over him" didn't stop Kbar from being one of the highest posters in yesterday's thread. I wonder if this is a wolf-chat inside joke???

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
assasin is pretty powerful. He poisoned shortline and may have had more poison or was on his way to more poison. Poising a villager every 3 or 4 days in addition to the night kills is pretty damn powerful

[ QUOTE ]
No. Simply put, no. I metagame, hell yes. But 1) Kbar sucks at wolfing. 2) It's a huge mistake to do what he did (if bluff is a regular wolf) unless he has huge amounts of powers (and I don't think he did). In fact, I probably deliberately screw up my seer claim so I get pwned instead of bluff (this would be genius, but I don't respect kbar's wolf game enough).

[/ QUOTE ]

i dont believe you here. I'll drop it for now but im telling you i dont believe you

[/ QUOTE ]
Well, obviously, it depends on how powerful kbar was. But unless you have killing poison like every 2 days or so, and you know it, I don't think it's worth it to get a wolf lynched there. At that point, I am trying to set up metagame for my wolf buddies, not to get a fellow wolf lynched. You may not believe me, but you're wrong.

[metsandfinsfan]

mark is now 100% villager on my list