LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[Nez477]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
There are a lot of good reasons not to vote me. Neil

[/ QUOTE ]
Is it just me, or does this post suck, a lot?

aaronk.

[/ QUOTE ]

is it just me, or does this post suck, a lot?

[/ QUOTE ]
is it just me, or does this post suck, a lot? Because the first one didn't suck, a lot.

[/ QUOTE ]

yeah it's just you

[/ QUOTE ]


yuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuucky

aaronk->lastchance->soah->luckay->soah

[/ QUOTE ]

I know. This was the hammer that put me firmly in the Soah/LC boat yesterday during reread.

[lastchance]

I don't really have a response to that. It looks pretty freaking awful for me, but I have no clue what the wolves are thinking there. Perhaps they were trying to set me up? I really don't know.

And I think my initial post was good. Aaronk looked like wolf faking power role. Of course, he was actually a power role. -_-

[Nez477]

Alright, Day 1 recap:

Stephen is pretty UTR really. He pops in and makes an argument for Econophile which more or less says that Econo is a wolf and if he is then TFG would be as well. Not a good day for Stephen.

Lastchance votes TFG early in the day, first vote I think, for "A weird post". This is soah wolfish like. Vote for a fellow wolf for no real reason and then just kind of let it fade away. I know it's day one and votes are all over the place but Lastchance is joking around all day and makes no real contributions that are all that worthwhile IMO.

Day 1 is pretty much a tie.

Moving on to day 2.

[lastchance]

Remember, I'm generally more wolfy than Stephen is. Make sure to account for that.

[Stephen H]

And lastchance is here.
I'd refute that, but I'm honestly confused by what you're trying to say. But here goes:

I had no idea what the wagons were on Day 1. But, yes, my vote not on TFG doesn't look good. Of course, lastchance cleverly ignores the fact that he voted Voj day 1, which looks equally bad.

I'm not sure at all what you mean by "backs off when he's caught". Also, that last post quoted wasn't me trying to sound villagery. If it was, I quote it first thing, front and center, today to "prove how villagery i am". But it was made several days after Zurvan made the same mistake (for the same reasons...books looked REALLY REALLY bad after day 1, and no one really talked about why books was killed so it didn't stick into memories that books was nightkilled), so it's not really a good reason to clear someone.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
And lastchance is here.
I'd refute that, but I'm honestly confused by what you're trying to say. But here goes:

I had no idea what the wagons were on Day 1. But, yes, my vote not on TFG doesn't look good. Of course, lastchance cleverly ignores the fact that he voted Voj day 1, which looks equally bad.

I'm not sure at all what you mean by "backs off when he's caught". Also, that last post quoted wasn't me trying to sound villagery. If it was, I quote it first thing, front and center, today to "prove how villagery i am". But it was made several days after Zurvan made the same mistake (for the same reasons...books looked REALLY REALLY bad after day 1, and no one really talked about why books was killed so it didn't stick into memories that books was nightkilled), so it's not really a good reason to clear someone.

[/ QUOTE ]
Yeah, it does. But I wasn't here most of day 1 too. Class and such. You know Nez will reread thoroughly and find that post. You don't need to bring it up if you're a wolf. IMHO, it doesn't make you look good, it makes you look worse.

[Nez477]

Stephen,

FWIW, your voting for Econo day 1, making the post you did about him and then not acknowledging how bad it looked the next day, not even now, and saying LC's vote of Voj was just as bad, all look bad.

Day 2 recap coming in a sec.

[Nez477]

Day 2 is just plain sick and it is frustrating me.

Lastchance first:

You make the preliminary easy vote of the most powerful villager we have. You are good enough to realize that Traz doesn't ever ever do something as obvious on day 1 as a wolf. And you later kind of say that you aren't going to lynch him. And then you revote him? And then you try and control the day. You ask one sentence questions to IY, DMK, GT1T, and then clear the following as villagers with no discussion whatsoever:

"Kumu looks village" No explanation.
"IY wagon seems horrible" O RLY? No explanation

You make tons of general clearings without any discussion at all. It looks bad. And all of those cleared without discussion, like IY and Kumu were of course villagers.

Stephen:

As I said, you don't realize that saying Econo is a better lynch than TFG, but if Econo comes up wolf than lets lynch TFG is just horrid? You do say "Can we at least lynch Econo to see if I'm right?" on day 2 after TFG dies, which maybe makes it look a little less horrid.

You also say in a post that "Jeremy is not precluded from being a wolf" with no explanation at all, you don't mention him again that day.

This day is about even, you both have super wolfy looking first 2 days, I can see why IY was suspecting LC early, I can see why Stephen was getting some pressure/votes early.

Day 3. Please say that one of you do something villagery on day 3.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]

You make the preliminary easy vote of the most powerful villager we have. You are good enough to realize that Traz doesn't ever ever do something as obvious on day 1 as a wolf. And you later kind of say that you aren't going to lynch him. And then you revote him? And then you try and control the day. You ask one sentence questions to IY, DMK, GT1T, and then clear the following as villagers with no discussion whatsoever:


[/ QUOTE ]
There is one easy way to tell if traz is a wolf. It is when he is wrong. Traz being wrong generally = traz being wolf. Traz is really not that good a wolf, mostly because he is too good a villager.

Also, I knew we weren't going to lynch him that day, but I wanted info out of the best villager in the game, and he wasn't giving up freaking anything. I really was hoping he'd slip up somewhere against my attack. The fact that he didn't respond to gt1's attack for a while SUCKS, and there's absolutely no way anyone should be allowed to skate by a gt1 attack.

[Nez477]

Yay, day 3!

LC, you keep doing the exact same thing! You start the day saying who is village without any argument again.

But Soah starts the day voting for Stephen. Soah loves going after his fellow wolves, I've seen from personal experience and from his TFG vote day 1.

And as Stephen posted, the intereaction between LC/Soah day 3 is horrible looking for you LC. But i know you already adressed it.

WHY ARE YOU CLEARING VILLAGERS ALL THE TIME THOUGH? No explanation on like 7 "This person is villagery" posts over 2 days. And they are all, in fact, villagers.