LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
<ul type="square">[*]Item 1: Traz is a villager. This is due to his passionate villagery arguments today.[*]Item 2: Zurvan is a 100% villager, due to lynching Sauron.[*]Item 3: Aaronk and Soah are near 100% villagers, due to being key votes to lynching Sauron.[*]Item 4: GT1T looks extremely villagery from the tone of his posts on his deathbed.[*]Item 5: It looks like Jeremy was WDCBooks' peek. (Jeremy is a villager.)[/list]
FMXDA

[/ QUOTE ]

My initial thought is that luckay is trying to clear jeremy (who we now know are both wolves), and used a bunch of villagers to lead up to it. I'll quote his followup post when i called him on the BS of this as well.

Leans toward clearing zurvan/soah. However, soah is lumped in with aaronk - and luckay got this vote wrong. So soah is kind of suspicious as well from this. dmk isn't mentioned.

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Item 5: Books was almost certainly killed on "feel" and not on any sort of peek data. Jeremy is not precluded from being a wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]
feel? wtf?
Do you think the wolves got an Aragorn feel from him or something?

[ QUOTE ]
As traz pointed out, Aaronk was on GT1T. I've got him as HIGHLY SUSPICOUS

[/ QUOTE ]
okay, correct. Aaronk is in fact highly suspicious.

[/ QUOTE ]

Sadly, I didn't challenge either his logic on zurvan or soah, so we don't have a response to go on. But notice how his responses line up with the roles.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Item 5: Books was almost certainly killed on "feel" and not on any sort of peek data. Jeremy is not precluded from being a wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]
feel? wtf?
Do you think the wolves got an Aragorn feel from him or something?

[ QUOTE ]
As traz pointed out, Aaronk was on GT1T. I've got him as HIGHLY SUSPICOUS

[/ QUOTE ]
okay, correct. Aaronk is in fact highly suspicious.

[/ QUOTE ]

Sadly, I didn't challenge either his logic on zurvan or soah, so we don't have a response to go on. But notice how his responses line up with the roles.

[/ QUOTE ]
I don't think Luckay knew aaronk was aragorn at that point.

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
I don't think Luckay knew aaronk was aragorn at that point.

[/ QUOTE ]

Obviously I only care about wolf/non-wolf.
Luckay continued to defend Jeremy - wolf!
Luckay rolled on aaron without a fight - Village!

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I don't think Luckay knew aaronk was aragorn at that point.

[/ QUOTE ]

Obviously I only care about wolf/non-wolf.
Luckay continued to defend Jeremy - wolf!
Luckay rolled on aaron without a fight - Village!

[/ QUOTE ]
Meh. I really don't think there's anything Luckay said that could tell you about anything. IMHO, he's just way too high level a player.

[Stephen H]

This would be a lot easier if history didn't show that lastchance sounds this wolfy as any role.

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Zurvan, please take off the blinders on me, thx.

[/ QUOTE ]

[img]/images/graemlins/confused.gif[/img]

How do you know I haven't changed my mind on you?

I don't have time to post today, at least until late, but clown has basically posted nothing but defense of himself since day 1.

We shouldn't lynch stephen today. I wish we knew which of the hobbit life mates was targetted, so we know whose posts we should look at.

Don't lynch stephen.

Do lynch clown or nez.

Maybe traz, but maybe not, too.

[/ QUOTE ]

Zurvan, this was early day 3; you'd said the same basic sentiment end of day 2. Why so adamant about defending me here?

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
By the way, Sam, it's time to come out.

[/ QUOTE ]
Massive Neil = villager tell, if it wasn't clear already
(btw, Sam, it's not time to come out)

[/ QUOTE ]I'm assuming Nicholas is NOT Frodo, because it seems so bad to do so.

[/ QUOTE ]
Neil, STFU. Sam, if you do not know Nich's role, you should come out right now. Otherwise, everyone should STFU about Nich's role.

[/ QUOTE ]

Lastchance, I'd like to hear what you were thinking at this point.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]
This would be a lot easier if history didn't show that lastchance sounds this wolfy as any role.

[/ QUOTE ]
This is what lastchance says as a villager (see ST2). Is it what StephenH says as a villager?

I don't know.

[lastchance]

[ QUOTE ]

Lastchance, I'd like to hear what you were thinking at this point.

[/ QUOTE ]
That it was fairly likely that NichP was Sam, and I didn't want wolves to figure it out.