AMERICAN IDOL SEASON 2: EVEN BETTER

[ScottHoward]

people, mets is a wolf vote mets

[Nicholasp27]

sigh
ok

scenarios:

jonsan wolf, donny villager: why would jonsan not only say it's one of those 2 (getting wdc on him) and then ALSO have us all switch from donny to kbar at the last minute if he's a wolf that knows they are both villagers? he's not gonna be that obvious; come on now

jonsan wolf, donny wolf: he may have done it then; still risky, but the only way he does it is if donny is wolf imo

jonsan villager, donny wolf: def possible by jonsan's play; he's villager and doesn't know the wolves so we can't tell by what he did

jonsan villager, donny villager; def possible as above


therefore, jonsan is likely a villager, but if he's a wolf it's almost always only when donny is as well

[Don West]

I'm starting to agree with VR, as Donny is the likely lynch this round. I doubt if Donny and Jonsan were both wolves, Jonsan would make it super obvious as to start a new 13th hour bandwagon on someone else.

IMO if Donny = Judge(wolf)
Jonsan = contestant (probably Kevin Covais)

[wdcbooks]

[ QUOTE ]
people, mets is a wolf vote mets

[/ QUOTE ]

Wow, I had forgotten that Scott and Mets were playing.


That isn't a compliment.

[metsandfinsfan]

I dont think jonsan or donny is a wolf at this point

I would much rather vote WDC or VR right now

[Jonsan]

I'm back. I have sesami chicken with an extra side of steamed broccoli. I think there is a spring roll too. And a fortune cookie.

Donny still looks good to me. I was wrong about kbar. It happens. Nick also looks good.

[ChrisV]

The 2 bandwagon theory works OK. It's the part about auto-lynching the other bandwagon on day 2 that doesn't.

[metsandfinsfan]

[ QUOTE ]
The whole 2 bandwagon theory annoys me to no end, mostly becuase people get hung up on it on the second day...case and point

[/ QUOTE ]

i agree

[Thebram]

vote jonsan

[Don West]

[leftfield][ QUOTE ]
people, mets is a wolf vote mets

[/ QUOTE ]
[/leftfield]