AVERAGE SPEED VIII: GAME THREAD

[soah]

This is tough because you are both missing several days, which leaves a pretty big gap in trying to solve this puzzle.

The strongest evidence for OH being villager is Day 1, when he votes chuckles to make it 4-4. Even here, though, it's uncertain if this is actually villagery or if it's just acknowledging that a wolf will go down and trying to look good. fnord votes Patton right after that, and so does OH.

Day 2, lots of posts, not a lot of content. There was one post in particular at 4:49 that I did not like about books, although you did switch vote to Luckay a little bit later, not sure what to make of it really.

Day 3, nothing. Day 4 you can only get in a single post. It happened to be right when everyone voted chuckles, which you did as well. Once again, I have no way to determine if that's a villagery thing, or if you saw a lot of interest in chuckles and just went along with it.

Day 5, you say that you don't think that the books kill was a seer hunt, you think it was a setup of Horn... although on Day 6 you do want to lynch him (along with all the rest of us).

After that, with the fnord thing, you once again had a hand in it, but once again you were one of the last to join in.

I've been looking for villagery signs from you and as I said, the best I could come up with was Day 1. It has mostly been ambiguous, and IMO getting worse as the game progressed. You've played a part in lynching all of the wolves, but never led the charges yourself. You said yourself while arguing for a SH lynch that the wolves were trying to get it to a 3v2 round... yet this argument makes Nich seem clearest out of us three. You switched off of fnord to vote SH, and Nich urged you to switch back. And fnord was gunning for Nich. First level thinking tells me that he is the villager, and you are the wolf.

[Our House]

[ QUOTE ]
Day 3, nothing. Day 4 you can only get in a single post. It happened to be right when everyone voted chuckles, which you did as well. Once again, I have no way to determine if that's a villagery thing, or if you saw a lot of interest in chuckles and just went along with it.

[/ QUOTE ]
That was my first post since I got back home from the ER. I didn't pay any attention to the exact timing because I was dictating to GT1T and not looking at the thread. If it got posted at a bad time, it wasn't my doing.

[ QUOTE ]
Day 5, you say that you don't think that the books kill was a seer hunt, you think it was a setup of Horn... although on Day 6 you do want to lynch him (along with all the rest of us).

[/ QUOTE ]
On day 5, I really did believe it was a setup kill. Horn was acting like a villager and even asked me to be masons with him. On day 6, there were two consecutive night kills that implied Horn - Books and someone else (I forgot who) and day 6 is when I put 2 and 2 together.

[ QUOTE ]
After that, with the fnord thing, you once again had a hand in it, but once again you were one of the last to join in.

[/ QUOTE ]
I did lead that charge, and I was one of the first to vote Fnord. Scott started acting like a douche and got me to switch to him right before I went to sleep. When I woke up again, a lot had gone down, and I immediately switched back to Fnord.

[ QUOTE ]
First level thinking tells me that he is the villager, and you are the wolf.

[/ QUOTE ]
If I get voted off, the village loses.

[Our House]

I don't know where Nich is and it's 8:50 already. The disappearing act isn't fair to us at all.

[Our House]

I don't mind making the wrong call or vote, but if I lose to a wolf that only pops in for a quick statement -- but not to discuss -- I'm going to get upset.

[Our House]

Is anyone here?

[Our House]

Soah, none of that was directed at you, BTW. It looks like you're really trying.

[soah]

I'm not sure about my point on fnord now that I look again. I think some of the confirmeds were really screaming about lynching him while he was still near the bottom of your list. But then after bobo turned up villager, fnord jumped straight to the top of your list.

[Our House]

Is this some sort of joke game where all of us are villagers? Nah, I doubt durron would do that in an Avg Speed.

OK, anyway...we have 15 minutes and no one is around. WTF?

[Our House]

[ QUOTE ]
I'm not sure about my point on fnord now that I look again. I think some of the confirmeds were really screaming about lynching him while he was still near the bottom of your list. But then after bobo turned up villager, fnord jumped straight to the top of your list.

[/ QUOTE ]
Fnord went to the top because:

1) Both Zurvan AND BobO turned up villagers.

2) He was next in my lynch order.

[soah]

O RLY? You wrote: "I believe BobO -> Scott -> Zurvan -> Fnord is the way to go."