*Official Fantasy Football "What Do You Think of This Trade" Thread*

[Novles]

K, help me out, I've been offered Peyton, Michael Jenkins, and Houshmandzadeh for Vick, Holt, and Ward.

My quarterbacks are Vick and Bledsoe. Receivers are Holt, Ward, Djax, Wilford, and Cotchery.

Start 1 QB and 3 WR, standard yahoo scoring, except 25 passing yds/1 point and 10 rush/rec yds/1 point. Thanks

[4_2_it]

I can get Cadillac Williams for DJax and Rhodes.

Caddy would play my flex and I would rotate Mason, Edwards and Berrien in my #2 reciver slot. (My starting backs are Tiki and Chester.)

[kyro]

[ QUOTE ]
K, help me out, I've been offered Peyton, Michael Jenkins, and Houshmandzadeh for Vick, Holt, and Ward.

My quarterbacks are Vick and Bledsoe. Receivers are Holt, Ward, Djax, Wilford, and Cotchery.

Start 1 QB and 3 WR, standard yahoo scoring, except 25 passing yds/1 point and 10 rush/rec yds/1 point. Thanks

[/ QUOTE ]

I hate this trade for you. Just looking at the combined points I'd expect these guys to score, I think you lose.

[Novles]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
K, help me out, I've been offered Peyton, Michael Jenkins, and Houshmandzadeh for Vick, Holt, and Ward.

My quarterbacks are Vick and Bledsoe. Receivers are Holt, Ward, Djax, Wilford, and Cotchery.

Start 1 QB and 3 WR, standard yahoo scoring, except 25 passing yds/1 point and 10 rush/rec yds/1 point. Thanks

[/ QUOTE ]

I hate this trade for you. Just looking at the combined points I'd expect these guys to score, I think you lose.

[/ QUOTE ]

But it's PEYTON MANNING. j/k yeah I know, my receivers would be horrendous. So you think Vick can keep it up?

[Burdzthewurd]

Standard Yahoo 10-team H2H league

I just got offered Brady and W. Parker for Frank Gore

My other RB's are J. Jones, Portis, McAllister, C. Williams

My QB's are Hasselbeck and Culpepper

Pretty sure I don't NEED this trade, nor do I have a desire to drop any of my receivers (except maybe Crotchery), just want to see if this is a great deal or not.

[Black Aces 518]

[ QUOTE ]
Standard Yahoo 10-team H2H league

I just got offered Brady and W. Parker for Frank Gore

My other RB's are J. Jones, Portis, McAllister, C. Williams

My QB's are Hasselbeck and Culpepper

Pretty sure I don't NEED this trade, nor do I have a desire to drop any of my receivers (except maybe Crotchery), just want to see if this is a great deal or not.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think it's pretty terrible. You have really good depth at RB. If you're gonna trade one, get something that really improves you. I don't think Brady is a huge upgrade over what you have now, esp minus Branch.

[toohigh]

Which team gets the better end of this six player deal and why? This is for a 12 team, H2H, standard CBS SportsLine scoring league, start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 DST.

This deal would be effective for Week 4, not this week.

Team A gets:
Frank Gore, Todd, Heap, Jake Plummer

Team B gets:
LaMont Jordan, Eli Manning, Jermaine Wiggins

Team A

Matt Hasselbeck
Eli Manning
Mike Bell
LaMont Jordan
Ahman Green
Laurence Maroney
Troy Williamson
Drew Bennett
Deion Branch
Rod Smith
Bernard Berrian
Jermaine Wiggins
Neil Rackers
DST Bengals

Team B

Jake Plummer
Trent Green
David Carr
Frank Gore
Cadillac Williams
Willie Parker
Chester Taylor
Andre Johnson
Donte' Stallworth
Mark Clayton
Ben Troupe
Todd Heap
Rian Lindell
DST Patriots

[IggyWH]

I have Addai & Duce McAllister on my bench. Other team has Cadillac and is in need of a RB. Worth trying to trade either Addai or McAllister for Cadillac?

If I can't do either straight up, do I walk away or try to add to the deal some? I got some quality WR's on the bench and his WR's are horrible.

[toohigh]

[ QUOTE ]
I have Addai & Duce McAllister on my bench. Other team has Cadillac and is in need of a RB. Worth trying to trade either Addai or McAllister for Cadillac?

If I can't do either straight up, do I walk away or try to add to the deal some? I got some quality WR's on the bench and his WR's are horrible.

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm all for trading for players when their value is relatively low, but Cadillac has to prove to me that he has ANY value before I trade for him. He is inconsistent, and hasn't shown that he can handle the full workload of a NFL starting RB yet.

WR is a great position to be deep at, as you can lose players trading at this position with the lowest risk, IMO.

[IggyWH]

I like Caddy because :

a)Gruden has shown a total man love for Simms so far this year, which hasn't worked out at all. He has to invest in the run sometime really soon, and when he does, I expect Caddy to break out of his slump. The dude only has like 22 carries so far this year. That's not nearly enough action to think that he is a bust.

b)Caddy has been hurt (back spasms), which could explain the low production so far.

c)Other team is probably desperate for a RB and can't wait to see of Caddy will surive. I can survive if Caddy doesn't turn things around, but if he does, I could be money.