*Official Fantasy Football "What Do You Think of This Trade" Thread* 2

[dknightx]

need URGENT feedback on this trade:

I get: Mcgahee, Reggie Bush, Reggie Wayne
He gets: LT, Turner, Furrey

I need serious RB help ... I end up starting LT and Turner each week as my other RBs are Turner, Buckhalter, lendale white. My current WR are Randy Moss, Joey Galloway and Furrey.

[capone0]

I wouldn't take it. LT >>> Bush + McGahee. McGahee doesn't score TDs although his schedule is good for the rest of the season and Bush is overrated. He doesn't do much. Wayne is a big upgrade but I can't see giving up the #1 RB right now for that. LT is way too valuable. Bush isn't and McGahee is marginally good. You can't give up #1 players so easily.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
need URGENT feedback on this trade:

I get: Mcgahee, Reggie Bush, Reggie Wayne
He gets: LT, Turner, Furrey

I need serious RB help ... I end up starting LT and Turner each week as my other RBs are Turner, Buckhalter, lendale white. My current WR are Randy Moss, Joey Galloway and Furrey.

[/ QUOTE ]

Wow your team sucks but I dont think you are getting quite enough to get rid of LT. Arent there any RBs on waivers that you can crab like washington or lundy or someone?

[dknightx]

as commish of my league, i just saw this trade accepted:

Westbrook

for

Steve Smith
Julius Jones

I want to veto this soooo bad ...

[dknightx]

OK, I just received this offer for LT, from my previus post:

I need serious RB help ... I end up starting LT and Turner each week as my other RBs are Turner, Buckhalter, lendale white. My current WR are Randy Moss, Joey Galloway and Furrey.

I get: stephen jackson, jamal lewis, djack, d mason
I give: LT, randy moss

this will give me a starting roster of:

RB1: s jackson
RB2: jamal lewis
WR1: Djack
WR2: Joey galloway
WR3: Furrey
WR/RB: dmason/turner

i play in a 14 team league so there is NO ONE on the waviers (the only RB are 3rd stringers)

[capone0]

I'd take it. Only b/c D. Jack is included. LT is still better than Jackson and Jamal almost combined in most leagues. So do you think Randy Moss is as good as DJack this year, nope. I'll take it but I wouldn't be that happy. Jamal Lewis is one of the worst starting RBs in the league most weeks although he did play well this week. What's he averaging like 3.3 YPC.

[NLSoldier]

dk,

take this one easily.

[capone0]

Okay. Here is a balsy trade only b/c I want to make sure I have a top flight QB at the end of the season incase Peyton sits. I'm thinking about trading for Hasselback now that he's injured to a team that's in shambles.

My Team:

QB: Peyton
RB: Gore, Green, T. Bell, M. Bell, C. Williams, L. Washington
WR: Horn, Williams, Evans, Walker, Stallworth
TE: Gates
K: Gould
Def: Chicago

His team:

QB: Favre, Hasselback, Carr
WR: Re. Williams, Bruce, Welker, Chambers, Ma. Clayton
RB: R. Johnson, R. Bush, K. Barlow
K: Akers
Def: Jacksonville, St. Louis (?)

This is his first year to play. He's already made a horrible trade earlier in the year where he gave up Holt for stuff that looked decent at the time but is horrible now.

Now Hasselback in week 12 plays GNB, weeks 13 plays Den, week 14 plays Arizona, week 15 plays SFO, and week 16 plays SDG.

Peyton plays Phi, @Ten, @Jac, Cin, @Hou the same 5 weeks including the last 2 which are the playoffs. If the Colts win this week as others have stated, they will have a 2 or really a 3 game cushion on both the Pats and Broncos. I would cringe if Peyton sits against Houston. I know week 16 won't be that great against SDG but the Seahawks will probally have to win that game to either win the division or get into the playoffs.

Anyones thoughts on who or what to give? I was thinking about trading Cadillac and a wide reciever such as Horn or Evans. I'm not really interestied in trading Stallworth due to Philly's schedule, trading Roy Williams b/c he's Roy and Walker b/c he's been very solid in most games.

This is a 10 yd = pt for rushing and receiving league and a 6 pts for both running, receiving and passing TDs (so a QB friendly league) with 25 yards per pass, -2 for int and -1 for a sac.

I know that under most circumstances this isn't the fairest of trades b/c Hasselback is usually a top 5 QB thing if he's healthy, this is a gamble by me and I probally won't ever play him. But he has Favre whose been good lately and has a favorable schedule as well. Should I even consider trading for Favre (I really don't want to)? I don't think he'd do it now anyway.

[NLSoldier]

Considering how awful his running back situation is, and the fact that he will still have favre, I think you can get him for caddy striaght up.

Your team is [censored] sick btw. How the hell did you get all those WRs?

[MacGuyV]

Villian needs a QB and I've received the following offer:

He gets: either Brees or Vick, Tatum Bell & Driver
I get: Pennington & Rudi Johnson & Reggie Brown

His QB/RB/WR roster:
Pennington, Leinart
R. Johnson, Rhodes
R. Moss, R. Brown, Cothery, R. Smith, Gates

Mine:
Brees, Vick
McGahee, T. Bell, L. Washington
Ward, Driver, Horn, Evans

Obv. I need a RB and I put in a bid to pick up Mike Bell or Maroney with the intention of dropping Washington. I'm not sure whether they'll clear waivers or not. Is the trade a good one for me regardless? I feel like it might be a good time to sell high on Vick, and who knows about T. Bell's immediate future. I'm not sure why he threw in the WR swap or who he meant that to be an upgrade for: probably a wash but I personally prefer Driver even though he has fewer TD's.

Thanks for any feedback.