LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[Neil S]

Oh yes that reminds me:

So who did you protect last night, Aaron?

And do we have a report from Sam or Frodo?

[Zurvan]

Nich:

[ QUOTE ]
because lynching villagers sucks, and aaron is not a villager

[/ QUOTE ]

No seer makes this post (at least, not a smart seer) if he hasn't peeked aaron as wolf.

Aaron goes next.

If you insist on trying to stop people from lynching aaron, you could draw out the real aragorn. That would be stupid, we follow the obvious instructions from the seer.

[Nicholasp27]

i thought he mentioned bram d2, so peeked bram evil n1...i thought peeked books villager n0, bram evil n1

[aaronk56]

Neil, obviously I protected Nich last night, the only good power character who is out other than me and I can't protect myself.

[dmk]

also,

when we said we shouldn't kill aragorn yesterday, traz said "you'll kill him tomorrow anyway"

now we know why

[Neil S]

Bram tonight, Aaron tomorrow. Let's go with the orders from traz. He obviously knew he was dying last night. He had to have done his best to tell us all he knew.

[Neil S]

Er, Bram today game-time, tonight real time, heh. Stupid no-edit rule.

[Nicholasp27]

[ QUOTE ]
Nich:

[ QUOTE ]
because lynching villagers sucks, and aaron is not a villager

[/ QUOTE ]

No seer makes this post (at least, not a smart seer) if he hasn't peeked aaron as wolf.

Aaron goes next.

If you insist on trying to stop people from lynching aaron, you could draw out the real aragorn. That would be stupid, we follow the obvious instructions from the seer.

[/ QUOTE ]

how would that draw out the real aragorn? if aaron isn't aragorn, then aragorn needs to stay hidden, obviously


we are in NO RUSH to lynch aaron right now...why risk that he is aragorn? if he is, we are in HUGE trouble

we can always get him later...it'll play itself out

just like people wanting to go traz soon after i'd cleared him because he 'could be godfather'...it will play itself out


traz saw bram wolf more likely than aaron wolf, so bram is the play today

[Zurvan]

Nich

The odds that he saw aaron are the same as the odds he saw bram. 99.9%, leaving a little uncertainty for the brain fart possibility. A seer does not push like that if he doesn't have a wolf. Traz doesn't push like that, either. It was very out of character. If aaron is not a wolf, I highly doubt traz dies last night.

[aaronk56]

[ QUOTE ]
Nich:

[ QUOTE ]
because lynching villagers sucks, and aaron is not a villager

[/ QUOTE ]

No seer makes this post (at least, not a smart seer) if he hasn't peeked aaron as wolf.

Aaron goes next.

If you insist on trying to stop people from lynching aaron, you could draw out the real aragorn. That would be stupid, we follow the obvious instructions from the seer.

[/ QUOTE ]

Zurvan, Traz trusts his reads enough that he would say I'm evil, even if he didn't peek me, which he did not because if he had he would have known I'm not lying about my role.

Look back at how he never uses any qualifiers for thebram and then look at some of his posts regarding me. The most telling two were posted by Neil earlier today but i'll go find them and post them again for you.