*Official Fantasy Football "What Do You Think of This Trade" Thread* 2

[tj00]

I just got an offer I am not sure about. I think I have one of the better teams but I am in a 3 way tie for first. Standard scoring but you have to start 2 RB, 2 WR, 3 Flex (RB or WR), 1 QB, 1 TE and 1 DEF

Offer: Give - Dunn & Lee Evans
Get - Harrison & Chad Johnson

My Team:

RB:
Tiki
Dunn
Addai
Julius Jones
Norwood
Fargas

WR:
Wayne
Colston
Reggie Willams
Chambers
Lee Evans
Greg Jennings

Pros: If Johnson starts playing like it is 2005 then I think it is a great deal.

Cons: Thins me out at RB and give me a bigger reliance Colt players

Any help is greatly appreciated.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
How bad is this?

I give up Javon Walker and Cadillac Williams for Marvin.

Reasoning, I don't trust Javon. I think he's very talented but Plummer is terrible. Marvin will get TDs. He only has 3 now and he's gotten atleast 10 in god knows how many season.

I can afford to trade Cadillac since I will still have Tatum, Gore, Green, and Leon Washington after this week. Do you guys think it's a good deal or am I giving too much or not giving enough?

[/ QUOTE ]

I dont trust Walker much either.

You are decently deep are running back so I dont mind this. I think Tatum and Gore are almost always going to be better options than carnell anyways so you are just losing some depth.

I especially like it if you are overly weak at WR, aka walker was your number 1.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
I just got an offer I am not sure about. I think I have one of the better teams but I am in a 3 way tie for first. Standard scoring but you have to start 2 RB, 2 WR, 3 Flex (RB or WR), 1 QB, 1 TE and 1 DEF

Offer: Give - Dunn & Lee Evans
Get - Harrison & Chad Johnson

My Team:

RB:
Tiki
Dunn
Addai
Julius Jones
Norwood
Fargas

WR:
Wayne
Colston
Reggie Willams
Chambers
Lee Evans
Greg Jennings

Pros: If Johnson starts playing like it is 2005 then I think it is a great deal.

Cons: Thins me out at RB and give me a bigger reliance Colt players

Any help is greatly appreciated.

[/ QUOTE ]

2 RB 2 WR AND 3 flex? That is an insane number of players.

If this is true you should be trying to start as many running backs as possible. This trade would make you pretty darn weak at RB so I dont really like it unless you think you can turn around and trade these WRs for better RBs.

Anyways, plz clarify that you do indeed start a total of 2 RBs and 2 WRs in addtion to 3 more flex spots and I will try to give better advice.

[La Brujita]

im in first in a 12 team cbs league, we need to start 3 wrs, 1 qb

i have favre and plummer,

driver, gabriel, holt, mason p. price.

offer is carson palmer for driver.

i don't think i can do that right?

what is a reasonable counteroffer.

he has

troy brown moose, steve smith, marcus robinson.

not that it makes much of a difference, or perhaps it does, but he has eli manning and picked carson p up on waivers after someone dropped him.

[NLSoldier]

im not gonna look at numbers but off the top of my head it looks like a bad deal for you.

driver appears to be your clear number 2 receiver and without him you would really really but hurting to find a decent number 3 to start each week. I dont think the upgrade from favre to palmer is nearly enough to make up for the awful wr situation you would be putting yourself in.

[SossMan]

I have an offer of: Plaxico, K. Jones, and L. Washington
for
Torry Holt

Do I even have to tell you the rest of my team and my scoring system? Does it matter?

[Spellmen]

Yes, who would you have to drop to make this deal?

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
I have an offer of: Plaxico, K. Jones, and L. Washington
for
Torry Holt

Do I even have to tell you the rest of my team and my scoring system? Does it matter?

[/ QUOTE ]

I think i only matters if you have two other RBs who are better or comparable to K jones.

If not, Id take it.

[Black Aces 518]

My team:

RB: S. Jackson, C. Williams, F. Taylor, D. Williams
WR: P. Burress, T. Glenn, M. Colston, B. Edwards, C. Henry, E. Parker

Start 2 RB and 2 WR. I'm offered LaMont Jordan and Anquan Boldin for Fred Taylor and Terry Glenn.

Take it?

[Tom1975]

My running backs are C. Ports, L. Betts, F. Taylor, M. Drew-Jones, S. Alexander and M. Morris. This week I'm starting Taylor and Morris (yuck). I have been offered Warrick Dunn for D. Jackson. I'm deep at WR but D. Jackson is my #1 WR. I could use Dunn this week but if Alexander and Portis are back and healthy in week 9 I should be ok at RB, but that's a big if. What do you think?