*Official Fantasy Football "What Do You Think of This Trade" Thread*

[xorbie]

[ QUOTE ]
Ok, He's offering me McGahee & Djax for Portis.
Thoughts?
Relevant people on my team:

Portis
Rudi
Dunn
T. Jones
K. Jones

TO
Rod Smith
S. Moss
D. Bennett
I. Bruce

[/ QUOTE ]

good lord this is such an easy trade, between rudi, dunn and mcgahee you have RB covered easily and now you will have very good RB on top of it.

[BWebb]

Thoughts on trading DJax for R. Williams in a dynasty league, with a PPR, for this year and the future? I have DJax and Branch and I'm not liking having to start 2 WR from the same squad.

[Victor]

[ QUOTE ]
Thoughts on trading DJax for R. Williams in a dynasty league, with a PPR, for this year and the future? I have DJax and Branch and I'm not liking having to start 2 WR from the same squad.

[/ QUOTE ]

not sure what dynasty or ppr means but why would you trade a good wr on a good team in an easy division that should contend for years for a sucky wr on a bad team with no future.

[BWebb]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Thoughts on trading DJax for R. Williams in a dynasty league, with a PPR, for this year and the future? I have DJax and Branch and I'm not liking having to start 2 WR from the same squad.

[/ QUOTE ]

not sure what dynasty or ppr means but why would you trade a good wr on a good team in an easy division that should contend for years for a sucky wr on a bad team with no future.

[/ QUOTE ]

Dynasty means players on your team carry over for years to come. PPR=point per reception. Therefore, when making trades you need to factor in age as well. Roy is 3 years younger, so the question boils down to "is giving up some production this year for a supposed better future worth it?"

[Victor]

"o the question boils down to "is giving up some production this year for a supposed better future worth it?" "

i dont think rw is gauranteed any production in the future.

[Black Aces 518]

[ QUOTE ]
Thoughts on trading DJax for R. Williams in a dynasty league, with a PPR, for this year and the future? I have DJax and Branch and I'm not liking having to start 2 WR from the same squad.

[/ QUOTE ]

I wouldn't do it. I would need a little more value than RW at this point.

[Madtown]

[ QUOTE ]
Dynasty league, scoring only (ie, TDs/2pt conversions, or FG/XP for kickers). Less than 10 YD TDs = 6, 10-39 YD TDs = 9, 40+ YD TDs = 12. Scoring TDs out of position (rush TDs for QBs, recieving for RBs, etc) = double points.



I give up my first round pick in next year's rookie draft for Brian Westbrook.

My RBs are Caddy, Julius Jones, Frank Gore, Michael Turner and Verron Haynes, with Dom Davis on IR.

Factoring in that we get double points for receiving TDs from running backs, I think Westbrook for a (hopefully low) first round rookie is a steal. Thoughts?

[/ QUOTE ]

Pulled the trigger on this, still wouldn't mind some thoughts on it.

[xorbie]

madtown,

looks ok, especially considering you have good RB the way it is. that said i don't know much about NCAA RB who might be very good.

[Black Aces 518]

League is 12 teams, 6 points for all TDs. Start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR.

My team is:
QB: Bulger, Green
RB: C. Williams, S. Jackson, F. Taylor, B. Jacobs
WR: T. Glenn, P. Burress, J. Galloway, B. Edwards, M. Colston, M. Clayton

Opp. has
QB: P. Manning, D. McNabb
RB: J. Lewis, A. Green, V. Morency, C. Benson, M. Anderson
WR: L. Coles, E. Kennison, J. Horn, R. White, M. Muhammad

TE, K, and D are irrelevant here.

He is interested in trading McNabb. What should I offer? What should be my worst case scenario?

[xorbie]

you will probably have to give up way more than you should. your team doesn't really have enough strength at either RB or WR for you to most likely be giving up a solid player at both positions.